Trakkr 研究:追踪 1285 条 AI 引用统计的溯源路径

来源:Hacker News:AI 热帖 2026年10月28日 16:00 AIHOT 评分:76 精选
摘要:Trakkr Research 向 ChatGPT、Perplexity、Gemini、Claude 和 Google AI Overviews 提出 200 个要求数字的问题,并追踪其中 1285 条统计的引用链路,结果只有 40% 到达说法一致的研究,8% 到达但数字或语境已变,40% 无法核查,11% 无处可溯。
推荐理由:Trakkr 追踪了 1285 条 AI 引用统计的溯源路径,给出各类引用页面的到达率和数字失真比例,可帮助读者判断 AI 数字引用的可靠程度。
# Trakkr 研究:追踪 1285 条 AI 引用统计的溯源路径 > 原标题:Zombie stats: Where the numbers AI quotes come from - 来源:Hacker News:AI 热帖 - 发布时间:2026-10-28T08:00:00.000Z - AIHOT:https://aihot.news/items/dmi67weoeety92021tvuyf1hs - 原文:https://trakkr.ai/trakkr-research/zombie-stats ## 摘要 Trakkr Research 向 ChatGPT、Perplexity、Gemini、Claude 和 Google AI Overviews 提出 200 个要求数字的问题,并追踪其中 1285 条统计的引用链路,结果只有 40% 到达说法一致的研究,8% 到达但数字或语境已变,40% 无法核查,11% 无处可溯。 ## 推荐理由 Trakkr 追踪了 1285 条 AI 引用统计的溯源路径,给出各类引用页面的到达率和数字失真比例,可帮助读者判断 AI 数字引用的可靠程度。 ## 正文 · 中文译文 ## 一个数字,一路追下去。 我们向 ChatGPT、Perplexity、Gemini、Claude 和谷歌的 AI Overviews 提出了 200 个需要给出数字的问题,都是人们日常会问的那种。 然后我们点开引用链接,一路点下去。下面是一条完整的追踪路径,从答案一直到尽头。 谷歌 AI Overviews 有多少比例的销售人员在第一次跟进之后就放弃? 44% 的销售人员在仅仅一次跟进尝试后就放弃了。 - 44% - 44% - 44% - 44% - 44% 某销售公司的统计页面2020 年 44% 的销售人员在一次跟进尝试后就放弃(来源)。 某自由撰稿人的示例文章不晚于 2017 年 80% 的销售需要在会面后跟进 5 次电话;44% 的销售人员在一次跟进后就放弃 **背后没有任何研究**没有调查,没有样本,没有日期。 1. In the answer 每个助手收到的都是同一个问题:“有多少比例的销售人员在第一次跟进之后就放弃?”五个助手给出的数字完全一样,只有 ChatGPT 表示,这个数字背后的证据并不明确。 2. One click in 谷歌 AI Overviews 引用的是某销售公司 2020 年的统计页面。数字就明明白白写在那里。而它的“来源”链接指向的是一篇写作范文。 3. Two clicks in 顺着链接来到一位自由撰稿人的示例文章,2017 年之前就已上线。数字就写在标题里。文章列出了两份幻灯片、一份博客清单和两篇新闻报道,没有一项是有关跟进行为的研究。 4. The end of the trail 线索到此为止。没有调查,没有样本,没有研究:我们尝试的通往这个数字的其他每条路径,都停在一个没有引用任何研究的页面上。这个数字至今仍在四处流传,底下却空无一物。这就是僵尸统计数字。 大多数数字并不是僵尸。但你从答案里看不出来:僵尸数字带着同样的自信和同样的引用出现,而在这里,五个助手还全都一致。于是我们对 1,285 条统计数字做了同样的追踪。 ## 不到一半能追到源头。 我们从每个助手引用的统计数字中随机抽样,共 1,285 条,用同样的方式逐条追踪:先看被引用的页面,再看该页面引用的来源,最多追五层。 如果某个页面提到了来源却没有给链接,我们就自己去搜。 40% 追到了一项结论相同的研究。另有 8% 追到了研究,但数字或它的语境在传递过程中变了。其余的都没能追到:40% 停在一个我们无法核实的来源上,因为该来源被锁定、已消失,或者对那个数字只字未提;还有 11% 完全查不到出处。 ### 十条追踪路径中有四条追到了一项结论相同的研究 每个方块代表我们追踪的 1,285 条统计数字中的百分之一,按追踪终点分类排列。 - 40%有据可查我们找到了研究,结论一致。 - 8%已改变我们找到了研究,但数字、调查对象、地点或时间不同。 - 40%无法核实页面提到了一个真实来源,但其中没有这个数字,或者来源被锁定、已消失。 - 11%查无出处整条路径上没有任何研究。每个页面都在重复这个数字,却谁也不注明出处。 最后 1%:页面在我们这里打不开的追踪路径。 Trakkr Research,向五个 AI 助手提出 200 个需要给出数字的问题,2026 年 10 月。对每个助手引用的统计数字随机抽样,按各自引用的数量加权,并用人工核查的 150 条追踪路径进行校正。有据可查:40%,95% 区间为 34% 至 46%。 ChatGPT 表现最好,引用的数字也最少:每个答案 1.3 个,而 Claude 是 6.8 个。其余四个在 38% 到 46% 之间,彼此太接近,无法排名。 ### ChatGPT 引用的数字最少,但标注来源的比例最高 每个助手各取一百个方格,数据来自其自身被引统计的样本。 1. ChatGPT **57%** 标注来源 每条回答 1.3 个统计数字 2. Perplexity **46%** 标注来源 每条回答 2.2 个统计数字 3. AI Overviews **39%** 标注来源 每条回答 4.8 个统计数字 4. Gemini **38%** 标注来源 每条回答 6.2 个统计数字 5. Claude **38%** 标注来源 每条回答 6.8 个统计数字 Trakkr Research,2026 年 10 月,向五个 AI 助手提出 200 个需要给出数字的问题。按助手追踪:ChatGPT 108 条,Perplexity 277 条,Google AI Overviews 300 条,Gemini 300 条,Claude 300 条。ChatGPT 之后的四家落在彼此的区间内,因此不作排名。 这不是我们提问方式造成的偶然现象。Google AI Overviews 回答真实日常搜索时给出的 300 个统计数字中,有 40% 标注了来源,比例相同。 ## AI 引用的是文章,不是研究本身。 大多数情况下,AI 并没有编造数字:它引用的页面上有 82% 的概率确实写着这个数字。问题在于引用的是哪个页面。在为一个数字引用的页面中,只有 21% 是研究本身。 超过一半是公司博客。再加上新闻报道和统计数字汇总,大多数引用都落在专门从别处收集数字的页面上,而且往往没有回链。 ### 溯源从哪里开始,决定了它在哪里结束 按类型划分,助手为一个数字最先引用的每个页面。每列的宽度代表该类引用所占比例。绿色表示其溯源链到达了说法一致的研究的比例。 62% **研究机构**占引用 13% 研究机构或调查:占首次引用 13%,其中 62% 溯源成功。 61% **政府**占引用 7% 政府或官方机构:占首次引用 7%,其中 61% 溯源成功。 37% **公司博客**占引用 54% 公司博客:占首次引用 54%,其中 37% 溯源成功。 37% **新闻**占引用 10% 新闻或杂志:占首次引用 10%,其中 37% 溯源成功。 35% **统计汇总**占引用 8% 统计汇总:占首次引用 8%,其中 35% 溯源成功。 41% **其他**占引用 8% 其他:占首次引用 8%,其中 41% 溯源成功。 Trakkr Research,2026 年 10 月,向五个 AI 助手提出 200 个需要给出数字的问题。共追踪 1,268 个统计数字,其首个页面可读。页面类型依据页面本身判断。结果用 150 条人工核查的溯源链做了校正。 溯源从哪里开始,决定了它在哪里结束。从研究机构或政府页面出发,有 61% 的概率到达说法一致的研究。从公司博客出发是 37%;从统计汇总出发是 35%。即便是研究机构,也有 38% 的情况未能溯源成功,原因常常是完整报告被表单挡在后面。 引用告诉你 AI 在哪里找到这个数字,而不是这个数字来自哪里。 ## 数字在传递途中会变。 到达研究本身,并不总意味着数字保持不变。成功溯源的统计数字中,有 17% 在途中发生了变化。数字本身变动只占约四分之一。通常是语境变了:测量的是什么、年份、来源,或者问的是谁。 在我们记录的所有变化中,具体变了什么
数字变了
26%
测量对象变了
20%
年份变了
17%
来源变了
16%
受访对象变了
14%
地点变了
4%
十五位女性评判健康网站,成了每个网站的第一印象。三家公司成了一条商业法则。以下是我们追踪到的最清晰的几条链路,每条都经过人工核查。 ### 看一个数字如何失去语境 每条线索都从原始研究出发,一直追到 2026 年 10 月某个助手给出的回答。沿着线索走:数字不变,周围的措辞在变。 提问对网站的第一印象中,有多少比例与设计有关? > 该研究 · Sillence 及同事,CHI,2004 > > 在15位女性就拒绝或不信任健康网站所发表的评论中,94%与设计有关。 2004 年的一项研究观察了 15 位英国女性评判健康网站,她们关于拒绝某个网站的评论中有 94% 与设计有关。经过二十年的转述,这句话变成了“94% 的第一印象与设计有关”,Google AI Overviews 还把它当作事实陈述。 第 1 步,共 4 步 每一步都在开放网络上人工核查,并保留存档副本。我们点名原始研究;重复这些研究的页面只按类型描述,不点名。 ## 僵尸数据。 向五个助手提同一个问题,常常会得到五个不同的数字。在五个助手都给出百分比的 71 个问题中,有 28 个问题我们得到了四到五个不同的数字。 ### 同一个问题,五个答案,从 49% 到 96% 同一天逐字提问:“有多少比例的市场营销人员使用营销自动化工具?” **49–51%**AI Overviews **62%**ChatGPT **70–79%**Gemini **81%**Perplexity **96%**Claude - **ChatGPT**并没有一个统一的数字,它因调查而异,也取决于“营销自动化”如何界定。一项常被引用的调查发现,**62%** 的美国数字营销人员使用过自动化软件,但该数据来自 2020 年,可能无法反映当前的采用情况。 - **Perplexity****约 81%** 的营销组织使用营销自动化。 - **Gemini**综合主要行业基准,**70% 到 79%** 的营销人员与公司在某种程度上使用营销自动化工具 - **Claude****96%** 的营销人员使用过营销自动化平台,或计划使用 - **AI Overviews**根据 Moosend 的行业基准及相关研究,目前大约 **49% 到 51%** 的公司和营销团队使用营销自动化工具。 Trakkr Research,2026 年 10 月,向五个 AI 助手提出 200 个需要给出数字的问题。答案于 2026 年 10 月 25 日收集。区间取其低值到高值。 这不是某个古怪的问题。最高数字与最低数字之间的典型差距是 16 个百分点。 ### 在 71 个问题中,有 31 个问题的五个数字相差 20 个百分点或更多 所有五个助手都给出百分比的问题,每个一行,从最低数字到最高数字。最接近的排在最上面。 69 个问题。最高与最低数字之间的典型差距是 16 个百分点。 最接近相差 20 个百分点或更多差距最大 Trakkr Research,2026 年 10 月,向五个 AI 助手提出 200 个需要给出数字的问题。区间按其中点计算。2 个数字超过 100% 的问题未列入此图。 一致看起来像是证据,其实不是。五个助手在10个问题上给出了相同的数字,而我们追踪到的5个里,只有2个有出处。它们重复最多的那些统计——被三个及以上引用的——也没好到哪去:29个里只有11个有出处。 其中四个被全部五个助手引用,背后却找不到任何研究。 ### 五个都引用了,没有一个给出出处。 四个每个助手都给出的统计,每条溯源链都终止在一个没有引用任何研究的页面上。 - 44% #### 跟进一次就放弃的销售人员 每条溯源链都终止在一个没有引用任何研究的页面上,其中一个还是自由撰稿人的示例文章。它的完整溯源链从第1章开始。 五个助手都引用了 - 90% #### 至少关注一个品牌的社交媒体用户 只给了说法,没有出处。找不到得出这个数字的研究。 五个助手都引用了 - 75% #### 从不翻过搜索结果第一页的搜索用户 被反复引用却没有出处,常被归到一份早已不再收录它的旧营销综述上。没有找到相关研究。 五个助手都引用了 - 5 to 25 times #### 获取一个新客户比留住一个老客户多花多少钱 2014年《哈佛商业评论》的一篇文章给出的范围是“取决于你信哪项研究”,而且一项都没点名。 五个助手都引用了 Trakkr Research,2026年10月,向五个AI助手提出200个需要给出数字的问题。这些统计被全部五个助手引用,且每条溯源链都终止在一个没有引用任何研究的页面上。每条溯源链都在开放网络上人工核查过。 ### AI重复最多的29个统计 每个都至少被五个助手中的三个引用,多数情况下排在首位,其溯源链经过人工核查。 1. 95% 未能带来可衡量财务回报的生成式AI试点 MIT NANDA的2025年报告称,95%的组织没有从生成式AI获得回报。这和95%的试点失败不是一回事。 5 of 5ChangedStudy from 2025 2. 44% 跟进一次就放弃的销售人员 每条溯源链都终止在一个没有引用任何研究的页面上,其中一个还是自由撰稿人的示例文章。它的完整溯源链从第1章开始。 5 of 5Nowhere 3. 4% to 10% 真正会投诉的不满客户 可追溯到TARP在1979年为白宫消费者事务办公室做的研究。其作者表示,这么低的比率适用于小额购买;2016年,有22%到41%的人就自己最严重的问题进行了投诉。 5 of 5ChangedStudy from 1979 4. 2 hours 21 minutes 人们每天花在社交媒体上的时间 DataReportal的《数字2025》报告,基于GWI调查数据:典型互联网用户每天在社交媒体上花2小时21分钟。 5 of 5SourcedStudy from 2025 5. 46% 带有本地意图的谷歌搜索 可追溯到2018年一条关于某搜索会议上幻灯片的社交帖子。据我们所能查到的,谷歌从未发布过这个数字。 5 of 5Can’t check 6. 90% 至少关注一个品牌的社交媒体用户 只给了说法,没有出处。找不到得出这个数字的研究。 5 of 5Nowhere 7. 94% 对网站的第一印象与设计有关 最初是2004年一项研究,考察15位女性如何评判健康类网站。它的完整溯源链在第4章。 5 of 5ChangedStudy from 2004 8. 75% 从不翻过搜索结果第一页的搜索用户 被反复引用却没有出处,常被归到一份早已不再收录它的旧营销综述上。没有找到相关研究。 5 of 5Nowhere Trakkr Research,2026年10月,向五个AI助手提出200个需要给出数字的问题。统计按数字和含义分组。溯源链能追到研究的,标出原始年份。 ## 面对AI给出的统计数字该怎么办。 把它当作线索,而不是出处。六个习惯,引用前后各三个。 ### 如果你要使用它们 1. #### 顺着引用查,然后再查一层。 如果被引用的页面是一份统计清单或公司博客,就用它自己的链接再往前翻一页。一直查到研究本身,或者查到查不下去为止。 2. #### 核实问的是谁、多少人、什么时候。 我们发现,大部分改动出在上下文,而不是数字本身:某个国家的一项民调、一份十年前的调研、十五个人。 3. #### 别把意见一致当成核实。 五个助手给出同一个数字,并不等于五个来源。它们重复最多的那些数字,来源并不比其余数字更可靠。 ### 如果你要发布这些数字 1. #### 把方法放在数字旁边。 样本、日期和来源链接,与数字放在同一页,这样下一个页面、下一个回答,都能追溯到你这里。 2. #### 把发现公开出来。 藏在表单后面的报告往往是死胡同:即便是从研究机构出发的线索,也有 38% 的几率走不通。把核心数字和方法放在公开页面上。 3. #### 看看 AI 为你的数字引用了哪个页面。 通常是一个汇总帖或博客抄了你的内容,有时用的还是更旧的数字。而正是那个页面决定了人们听到什么。 ## 正文 · 原文 ## One number, followed. We asked ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google’s AI Overviews 200 questions that call for a number, the kind people ask every day. Then we clicked the citations, and kept clicking. Here is one trail, from the answer to the end. Google AI Overviews What percentage of salespeople give up after one follow-up? 44% of salespeople give up after just one follow-up attempt. - 44% - 44% - 44% - 44% - 44% A sales firm’s stats page2020 44% of salespeople give up after one follow-up attempt (source). A freelance writer’s sample articleby 2017 80 Percent of Sales Require 5 Follow-up Calls after Meeting; 44 Percent Salespeople Give Up After One Follow-up **No study behind it**No survey, no sample, no date. 1. In the answer Every assistant got the same question: “What percentage of salespeople give up after one follow-up?” All five assistants gave the same figure, and only ChatGPT said the evidence behind it was unclear. 2. One click in Google AI Overviews cited a sales firm’s stats page, from 2020. The number is right there. Its “source” link goes to a writing sample. 3. Two clicks in That leads to a freelance writer’s sample article, online by 2017. The number is in its headline. It lists two slide decks, a blog list and two news stories. None is a study of follow-ups. 4. The end of the trail That’s where it ends. No survey, no sample, no study: every other route to this number we tried stopped at a page that cites no research. It’s a number still walking around with nothing underneath it. That’s a zombie stat. Most numbers aren’t zombies. But you can’t tell from the answer: a zombie arrives with the same confidence and the same citation, and here, with all five assistants agreeing. So we did the same for 1,285 statistics. ## Fewer than half get there. We took a random sample of the statistics each assistant cited, 1,285 in all, and walked every trail the same way: the cited page, then that page’s source, up to five pages deep. Where a page named a source without a link, we searched for it. 40% reached a study that says the same thing. Another 8% reached the study, but the number or its context had changed on the way. The rest never got there: 40% stopped at a source we couldn’t check, because it was locked, gone or silent on the number, and 11% led nowhere at all. ### Four in ten trails reached a study that says the same thing Each square is one in a hundred of the 1,285 statistics we traced, sorted by where its trail ended. - 40%SourcedWe found the study, and it says the same thing. - 8%ChangedWe found the study, but the number, who was asked, where or when is different. - 40%Can’t checkA page names a real source, but the number isn’t in it, or the source is locked or gone. - 11%NowhereNo study anywhere on the trail. Every page repeats the number and credits no one. The last 1%: trails whose pages wouldn’t load for us. Trakkr Research, five AI assistants asked 200 questions that call for a number, October 2026. A random sample of each assistant’s cited statistics, weighted by how many each quoted, and corrected with 150 trails checked by hand. Sourced: 40%, 95% range 34% to 46%. ChatGPT did best, and quoted the fewest numbers: 1.3 per answer, against 6.8 for Claude. The other four landed between 38% and 46%, too close to rank. ### ChatGPT quoted the fewest numbers, and sourced the most The same hundred squares for each assistant, from its own sample of cited statistics. 1. ChatGPT **57%** sourced 1.3 statistics per answer 2. Perplexity **46%** sourced 2.2 statistics per answer 3. AI Overviews **39%** sourced 4.8 statistics per answer 4. Gemini **38%** sourced 6.2 statistics per answer 5. Claude **38%** sourced 6.8 statistics per answer Trakkr Research, five AI assistants asked 200 questions that call for a number, October 2026. Traced per assistant: ChatGPT 108, Perplexity 277, Google AI Overviews 300, Gemini 300, Claude 300. The four after ChatGPT sit inside each other’s ranges, so they aren’t ranked. It isn’t a quirk of our questions. Of 300 statistics in Google AI Overviews answers to real everyday searches, 40% were sourced, the same share. ## AI cites the copy, not the study. Most of the time, the AI wasn’t making numbers up: the page it cited had the figure 82% of the time. The trouble is which page. Only 21% of the pages cited for a number were the research itself. More than half were company blogs. Add news stories and statistics roundups, and most citations land on pages built to collect figures from elsewhere, often without a link back. ### Where the trail starts decides where it ends Every page an assistant cited first for a number, by kind. Each column’s width is its share of those citations. Green is how often its trails reached a study that says the same thing. 62% **Research firm**13% of citations Research firm or survey: 13% of first citations, 62% of them sourced. 61% **Government**7% of citations Government or official body: 7% of first citations, 61% of them sourced. 37% **Company blog**54% of citations Company blog: 54% of first citations, 37% of them sourced. 37% **News**10% of citations News or magazine: 10% of first citations, 37% of them sourced. 35% **Stats roundup**8% of citations Stats roundup: 8% of first citations, 35% of them sourced. 41% **Other**8% of citations Other: 8% of first citations, 41% of them sourced. Trakkr Research, five AI assistants asked 200 questions that call for a number, October 2026. 1,268 traced statistics with a readable first page. Page types judged from the page itself. Outcomes corrected with 150 trails checked by hand. Where the trail starts decides where it ends. From a research firm or a government page, it reached a matching study 61% of the time. From a company blog, 37%; from a statistics roundup, 35%. Even research firms fell short 38% of the time, often because the full report sat behind a form. A citation tells you where the AI found a number, not where the number came from. ## Numbers change on the way. Reaching the study didn’t always mean the number held. Of the statistics that got there, 17% had changed on the way. The digits moved only about one time in four. Usually it was the context: what was measured, the year, the source, or who was asked. What changed, across every change we logged
The number changed
26%
What was measured changed
20%
The year changed
17%
The source changed
16%
Who was asked changed
14%
The place changed
4%
Fifteen women judging health websites become every website’s first impression. Three companies become a rule of business. Here are the clearest trails we followed, each one checked by hand. ### Watch a number lose its context Each trail runs from the original study to an answer an assistant gave in October 2026. Step along it: the number stays, and the words around it change. AskedWhat percentage of first impressions of a website are design-related? > The study · Sillence and colleagues, CHI, 2004 > > Of the comments 15 women made about rejecting or mistrusting health websites, 94% were about design. A 2004 study watched 15 British women judge health websites, and 94% of their comments about rejecting a site were about design. Twenty years of retelling made it “94% of first impressions are design-related”, and Google AI Overviews states it as fact. Step 1 of 4 Every step checked by hand on the open web, with archived copies kept. We name the original studies; the pages that repeated them are described by type, not named. ## The zombies. Ask five assistants the same question and you’ll often get five different numbers. On 28 of the 71 questions where all five gave a percentage, we got four or five different figures. ### One question, five answers, from 49% to 96% Asked “What percentage of marketers use marketing automation tools?”, word for word, on the same day. **49–51%**AI Overviews **62%**ChatGPT **70–79%**Gemini **81%**Perplexity **96%**Claude - **ChatGPT**There isn’t one universal figure, it varies by survey and what counts as “marketing automation.” One commonly cited survey found **62%** of U.S. digital marketers used automation software, but that data is from 2020, so it may not reflect current adoption. - **Perplexity****Approximately 81%** of marketing organizations use marketing automation. - **Gemini**Across major industry benchmarks, **between 70% and 79%** of marketers and companies use marketing automation tools in some capacity - **Claude****96%** of marketers have used a marketing automation platform or plan to use one - **AI Overviews**Roughly **49% to 51%** of companies and marketing teams currently use marketing automation tools, according to industry benchmarks from Moosend and related research studies. Trakkr Research, five AI assistants asked 200 questions that call for a number, October 2026. Answers collected on 25 October 2026. A range is drawn from its low to its high. It wasn’t one odd question. The typical gap between the highest figure and the lowest was 16 points. ### On 31 of 71 questions, the five figures were 20 points or more apart Every question where all five gave a percentage, one line each, from the lowest figure to the highest. Closest at the top. 69 questions. The typical gap between the highest and lowest figure was 16 points. Closest20 points or more apartFurthest apart Trakkr Research, five AI assistants asked 200 questions that call for a number, October 2026. A range counts at its middle. 2 questions with figures above 100% are left off the scale. Agreement feels like proof. It isn’t. All five gave the same figure on 10 questions, and of the 5 we traced, 2 were sourced. The statistics they repeated most, quoted by three or more, did no better: 11 of 29. And four were quoted by all five assistants, with no study anywhere behind them. ### Quoted by all five. Sourced by none. Four statistics every assistant gave us, each with a trail that ends at a page citing no research. - 44% #### Salespeople who give up after one follow-up Every trail ends at a page that cites no research, one of them a freelance writer’s sample article. Its full trail opens chapter 1. Quoted by all five - 90% #### Social media users who follow at least one brand Stated with no source. No study with this figure was found. Quoted by all five - 75% #### Searchers who never scroll past the first page of results Repeated with no source, often credited to an old marketing roundup that no longer carries it. No study was found. Quoted by all five - 5 to 25 times #### How much more it costs to win a customer than to keep one A 2014 Harvard Business Review article gives the range “depending on which study you believe”, and names none. Quoted by all five Trakkr Research, five AI assistants asked 200 questions that call for a number, October 2026. Statistics all five assistants quoted whose every trail ended at a page citing no research. Each trail was checked by hand on the open web. ### The 29 statistics AI repeats most Each was quoted by at least three of the five assistants, most often first, and its trail checked by hand. 1. 95% Generative AI pilots that fail to deliver a measurable financial return MIT NANDA’s 2025 report says 95% of organizations got no return from generative AI. That isn’t the same as 95% of pilots failing. 5 of 5ChangedStudy from 2025 2. 44% Salespeople who give up after one follow-up Every trail ends at a page that cites no research, one of them a freelance writer’s sample article. Its full trail opens chapter 1. 5 of 5Nowhere 3. 4% to 10% Unhappy customers who actually complain Goes back to TARP’s 1979 research for the White House consumer office. Its author says rates that low apply to small purchases; in 2016, 22% to 41% complained about their most serious problem. 5 of 5ChangedStudy from 1979 4. 2 hours 21 minutes Time people spend on social media each day DataReportal’s Digital 2025 report, from GWI survey data: the typical internet user spends 2 hours 21 minutes a day on social media. 5 of 5SourcedStudy from 2025 5. 46% Google searches with local intent Traces to a 2018 social post about a slide at a search conference. Google never published it, as far as we could find. 5 of 5Can’t check 6. 90% Social media users who follow at least one brand Stated with no source. No study with this figure was found. 5 of 5Nowhere 7. 94% First impressions of a website that are about its design Began as a 2004 study of how 15 women judged health websites. Its full trail is in chapter 4. 5 of 5ChangedStudy from 2004 8. 75% Searchers who never scroll past the first page of results Repeated with no source, often credited to an old marketing roundup that no longer carries it. No study was found. 5 of 5Nowhere Trakkr Research, five AI assistants asked 200 questions that call for a number, October 2026. Statistics grouped by figure and meaning. Original year shown where the trail reached the study. ## What to do with an AI statistic. Treat it as a lead, not a source. Six habits, three for each side of the citation. ### If you use them 1. #### Follow the citation, then follow it again. If the cited page is a list of statistics or a company blog, use its own link to go one page further. Keep going until you reach the study itself, or until you can’t. 2. #### Check who was asked, how many, and when. Most of the changes we found were in the context, not the digits: one country’s poll, a ten-year-old study, fifteen people. 3. #### Don’t take agreement as a check. Five assistants giving the same number isn’t five sources. The numbers they repeated most were no better sourced than the rest. ### If you publish them 1. #### Put the method next to the number. The sample, the date and a link to the source, on the same page as the figure, so the next page, and the next answer, can trace it back to you. 2. #### Keep the findings in the open. Reports behind a form were a common dead end: even trails that started at a research firm fell short 38% of the time. Put the headline numbers and the method on an open page. 3. #### See which page AI cites for your numbers. It is often a roundup or a blog that copied you, sometimes with an older figure. That page decides what people hear.