# Google 与 Reddit 同日股价大跌,AI 搜索变现困境冲击开放网络
> 原标题:What Google and Reddit's bad days have in common
- 来源:Platformer
- 发布时间:2026-10-30T00:51:00.000Z
- AIHOT:https://aihot.news/items/kzenjo9w2bfhpsr0ub1gr95xj
- 原文:https://www.platformer.news/thursday-newsletter-6/
## 摘要
Casey Newton 分析 Google 与 Reddit 同日遭遇的股市重挫:Alphabet 股价跌 12.6%,蒸发约 $5000 亿市值,为史上第二大单日市值缩水;高管承认 AI Mode 变现能力低于传统搜索,尽管 AI Mode 月用户约 10 亿、搜索收入仍增长 12% 至 $633.5 亿。
## 推荐理由
作者把 Google 和 Reddit 同日财报放在一起分析,指出 AI Mode 变现弱于传统搜索正在推动网站加门槛、让开放网络收缩。
## 正文 · 中文译文
[](https://mercury.com/payroll?utm_source=platformer&utm_medium=sponsored_newsletter&utm_campaign=26q4_brand_campaign)

_这是一篇关于 AI 的专栏。我的未婚夫在 Anthropic 工作。完整伦理披露见_[_此处_](https://platformer.news/ethics?ref=platformer.news)_。_
周四下午,Demis Hassabis [庆祝](https://x.com/demishassabis/status/2115933173175689570/photo/1?ref=platformer.news)了 Google AI 事业的一个里程碑:Gemini 4 Carbon——一款目前仅向网络防御人员开放的新大语言模型——登顶 Artificial Analysis 智能指数。此前新模型发布接连延期,外界越来越觉得这家公司正在掉出前沿阵营,而早期迹象显示,Carbon 标志着 Google 重回正轨。对 Alphabet 的首席科学家来说,这消息想必像是一场正名。
然而,投资者的看法远没有那么笃定。就在同一天,Google 母公司迎来了上市以来最糟糕的一个交易日。Alphabet 股价下跌 12.6%,市值蒸发约 5000 亿美元。这是史上第二大股市暴跌,仅次于英伟达 2025 年 1 月的 5930 亿美元缩水,也是 Google 自金融危机以来最大的单日跌幅。
抛售主要源于投资者对 Google AI 基础设施扩建规模的担忧。公司今年计划在资本支出上投入高达 2050 亿美元,并承诺 2027 年[还会花得更多](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/28/alphabet-googl-earnings-q3-2026.html?ref=platformer.news)。同时它报告的自由现金流为负 90 亿美元——上一季度开始的下降趋势进一步加速。
通常我不太在意股价的单日下跌,无论跌幅多大。(英伟达股价目前比 1 月时还高出 10% 以上。)但在财报电话会上,Google 首席商务官对一位分析师的提问给出了值得关注的回答。这位分析师问,为什么查询量在增长,搜索收入增长却在放缓。Philipp Schindler 说,原因之一是 Google AI Mode 使用量增加反而拖累了公司,因为它[比传统搜索赚得少](https://www.seroundtable.com/google-ai-mode-ads-earn-less-42417.html?ref=platformer.news)。
几小时后,Reddit 公布了自己的季度财报——股价[下跌 15%](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/29/reddit-rddt-q3-2026.html?ref=platformer.news)。公司称来自搜索的流量明显下滑,到第四季度日活用户可能下降百分之十几。因此,Reddit CEO Steve Huffman 在致股东信中表示,公司将[越来越多地推动用户登录](https://www.axios.com/2026/10/29/reddit-logged-in-ai-search-incognito?ref=platformer.news)后使用网站。几十年来人们(和机器人)都能免费浏览 Reddit,如今他们得先注册账号。
“这对我们的业务更有利,因为我们会获得更多用于广告定向的信号,而且登录通常带来更高的参与度,”Huffman [说](https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2026/10/reddit-will-require-you-to-log-in-eventually-ceo-confirms/?ref=platformer.news)。“这也能让我们保护 Reddit 极有价值的数据语料库的访问权限,并帮助我们更好地适应世界各地不断出台的监管规定。”
长期以来,Google 一直反驳“AI 答案对网络不利”的说法,称 AI 答案会促使人们进行更深入、更广泛的搜索,从而为网站带来更高质量的点击。今天的消息表明,这套说法正在瓦解:广告主从 AI Mode 得到的比传统搜索少,像 Reddit 这样的大型内容平台也是如此。
不过,虽然人们很容易指责谷歌在战略上犯了错,但我最终觉得它还是会胜出。而网络及其内容发布者将继续挣扎,谷歌则基本可以把这当作别人的问题一推了之。
到现在,大多数人已经熟悉谷歌与互联网之间那笔不断变化的交易。过去,发布者允许谷歌抓取自己的页面,谷歌则回馈以海量流量。谷歌从搜索结果中嵌入的广告里赚得盆满钵满,发布者则从访问其页面的人那里获得较少的收益。(去年,美国政府在一桩反垄断诉讼中胜诉,认定谷歌利用自身地位在广告市场建立了非法垄断,但按美国的一贯做法,该公司的垄断力量[几乎原封不动地保留了下来](https://publicknowledge.org/public-knowledge-warns-google-ad-tech-remedies-leave-monopoly-power-intact/?ref=platformer.news)。)
Reddit一直是谷歌所能输送流量的最大受益者之一。随着网络上大量内容被粗制滥造的东西淹没,真人撰写的对话变得更有价值,谷歌也开始在搜索结果中突出论坛讨论。Reddit的搜索流量随之激增;在该公司姗姗来迟地关闭了论坛对无休止抓取其内容的机器人的访问之后,据报道谷歌每年支付6000万美元来获得这些数据的授权。
但到2022年ChatGPT成为爆款时,谷歌已经花了很多年时间努力让用户在自己的页面上停留更久。这个最初作为通往更广阔网络的跳板,随着时间推移变成了一个可以直接在搜索结果页上找到答案的地方。发布者再也无法享有像“[超级碗几点开始](https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/01/a-brief-history-of-what-time-is-the-super-bowl/283497/?ref=platformer.news)”这样利润丰厚的套利机会;谷歌会自己回答你的问题。这或许在某种程度上是谷歌的贪婪,但也是对用户需求的明确回应。
我第一次使用ChatGPT时,[在我看来很明显](https://www.platformer.news/the-promise-and-the-peril-of-chatgpt/),它在各种谷歌搜索上的答案都明显更好。谷歌迟早必须做出回应,而它也确实回应了,推出了AI概览和AI模式。概览是显示在传统搜索顶部的那种方框;AI模式则是一个独立界面,可以从概览进入。无论如何,一年前谷歌高管[曾表示](https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-claims-ai-overviews-monetize-at-same-rate-as-traditional-search/547838/?ref=platformer.news),概览的变现效果与传统搜索大致相当;今天这条新闻之所以引起这么多人注意,一个原因就是它暗示AI模式——显然代表着许多高价值品类中搜索的未来——的变现效果并非如此。
需要说明的是,谷歌搜索仍然是一项庞大的业务:其搜索及相关广告收入增长了12%,达到633.5亿美元。但这低于第一季度的19%和第二季度的17%。与上一季度相比,这一数字[基本持平](https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-search-growth-slows-again-ai-mode/594862/?ref=platformer.news),尽管AI模式现在约有[10亿月活用户](https://mdm.co/alphabet-q3-2026-earnings-ai-modes-monetization-penalty/?ref=platformer.news),AI概览约有25亿。(辛德勒没有说明AI模式的收入低多少,也没有说明他具体是在跟什么比较。)
另外,不管这有没有参考价值:今年7月,谷歌CEO桑达尔·皮查伊告诉投资者,谷歌搜索中的AI功能[每周向网站发送数十亿次点击](https://blog.google/company-news/inside-google/message-ceo/alphabet-earnings-q2-2026/?ref=platformer.news)。而他本季度准备好的发言中,完全没有提到向网站发送点击一事。
皮查伊试图安抚投资者,把当下比作谷歌转向移动端的时刻——当时公司先专注产品,之后再大规模投放广告。而“之后”现在到了:谷歌正[把 AI 模式中的广告](https://blog.google/products/ads-commerce/ads-in-ai-mode-global/?ref=platformer.news)扩展到另外 10 个国家,并在美国为追问环节加入广告。(部分广告位包含简短的“AI 讲解”,由 Gemini 部分依据广告主自家网站撰写,广告主既不能编辑也无法审核。未来已来!)
按 Reddit 自己更保守的标准衡量,这季也算强劲。广告收入增长 54%,达到 8.47 亿美元。但美国日活用户再次下滑,从第二季度的 5320 万降至 5070 万。这已是连续第二个季度下降:7 月那次幅度小得多的下滑[从 5350 万降到 5320 万](https://www.fool.com/investing/2026/07/31/reddit-beat-on-revenue-profit-and-guidance-its-us/?ref=platformer.news),就曾让股价[一天内跌去约 22%](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/reddit-stock-plunges-choppy-search-155105779.html?ref=platformer.news)。在那次财报电话会上,霍夫曼说 AI 概览对 Reddit 的作用还比不上[传统的十条蓝色链接](https://money.usnews.com/investing/news/articles/2026-07-30/reddit-expects-revenue-above-estimates-as-ai-tools-attract-advertisers?ref=platformer.news)。几周前,《华尔街日报》报道称,在两家公司就授权协议续约谈判期间,Reddit 曾[讨论切断](https://www.wsj.com/business/media/google-search-publishers-ai-content-0fb06e41?ref=platformer.news)谷歌对其内容的 AI 访问权限。
这一切最终促成了登录界面的公布。霍夫曼在[自己账号的一篇帖子](https://www.reddit.com/user/spez/comments/1xiupm0/about_that_login_screen/?share_id=-jZXrl89CNtzwIJ8xMiwl&ref=platformer.news)里给出四点理由:更好的用户体验、更强的广告业务、安全监管,以及保护 Reddit 数据不被爬虫抓取。Reddit 本季度将开始在美国以外测试这一新体验,想必是为了估算此举会对用户数造成多大冲击。
霍夫曼对 _Axios_ 表示,他个人因信奉开放互联网而抵触这一改变,并称这不是对谷歌的回应,而是“为了打造最好的 Reddit”。
但把谷歌和 Reddit 这两件事放在一起,就形成了一个循环。谷歌的 AI 回答把更多价值留在自家页面上。网站失去流量,于是用门禁限制内容、靠出售访问权来应对。AI 回答随之更依赖授权数据,而那些付不起或不愿付钱的公司则被屏蔽或被起诉。(Reddit 在 2025 年就抓取问题起诉了 [Anthropic](https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/reddit-lawsuit-anthropic-ai-3b9624dd?ref=platformer.news) 和 [Perplexity](https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/perplexity-ai-loses-bid-toss-reddit-lawsuit-over-data-scraping-2026-07-31/?ref=platformer.news)。)
而这归根结底就是我确信谷歌不太需要担心今天这轮股市抛售的原因。无论授权内容多贵,谷歌都比几乎任何人都更付得起,而出版商大多乐意出售。(2024 年 Reddit 对网络爬虫关上大门时,谷歌是唯一保住实时 Reddit 结果访问权的主要搜索引擎。)
所以,尽管一个封闭且付费墙林立的网络会让谷歌每次回答的成本更高,谷歌仍有预算买单。而大多数挑战者没有——这再次说明,网络萎缩反而可能对谷歌有利,因为它让与谷歌竞争变得愈发昂贵。
这里的每一方都只是在为自己的长期利益行事,哪怕短期内会受损。我主要想指出的是后果:一个越来越小、阅读成本越来越高的网络;权力向平台集中;以及一个基本无动于衷的公众。(毕竟,除了那些习惯收割点击量的出版商,谁会主张十条蓝色链接的时代对读者更好呢?)
大概没人会——至少目前如此。对越来越多的问题来说,AI 模式确实是更好的产品,也很少有人会怀念在长长的链接列表里滚动翻找、只为找到最能回答问题的那个链接。
但如果说网络曾经算得上好用或有用,那很大程度上是因为那些链接所支撑的东西。没有了它们,互联网无论变成什么样,很可能都会更小、更不民主、也更昂贵。谷歌不会有事。我担心的是我们其他人。

**来自赞助商的消息**
### 薪资管理,内置于 Mercury
[](https://mercury.com/payroll?utm_source=platformer&utm_medium=sponsored_newsletter&utm_campaign=26q4_brand_campaign)
Mercury Payroll 是内置于你的 Mercury 账户的全方位薪资服务。你的信息已在档,因此设置只需 15 分钟。之后,注册、税务申报和全美 50 州的合规事宜都由我们处理。你只管招人,文书工作交给我们。
[了解更多 →](https://mercury.com/payroll?utm_source=platformer&utm_medium=sponsored_newsletter&utm_campaign=26q4_brand_campaign)
_\*Mercury 是一家金融科技公司,并非 FDIC 承保银行。银行服务由 Choice Financial Group 和 Column N.A. 提供,二者均为 FDIC 成员。_


**周五节目预告:**Kevin 和我将讨论 OpenAI 在数学、计算机科学和物理学领域的最新发现,以及这些发现引发的一些研究者的反弹。随后,我们将推出新栏目 Humans in the Loop:解答听众最关心的问题。
[**YouTube**](https://www.youtube.com/@machinegodspod?ref=platformer.news) **|** [**Apple**](https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/machine-gods/id6812430636?ref=platformer.news) **|** [**Spotify**](https://open.spotify.com/show/5kxu4uluMq6jUuoNPGyZMu?si=c3ec25c874154f04&ref=platformer.news) **|** [**RSS**](https://feeds.npr.org/g-s1-143588/podcast.xml?ref=platformer.news) **|** [**NPR**](https://app.npr.org/aggregation/g-s1-143588?ref=platformer.news)

## 关注
### OpenAI 对 AI 对齐的新思路
**发生了什么:OpenAI** [宣布](https://openai.com/index/updated-model-spec/?ref=platformer.news)已更新其模型规范——这是它在开发和部署 AI 时使用的行为指南——围绕“忠实于人类意图”这一原则展开。
该公司表示,它优先考虑“超越字面执行指令,深入理解 OpenAI、开发者和用户的意图与价值”。
OpenAI 新增了指令,确保其 AI 只采取[被允许的智能体操作](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#scope_of_autonomy),并遵循[社会规范](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#control_side_effects)。
但尤其有意思的是几处优先遵循用户意图的修改。
其中一项修改是让用户对 **ChatGPT** 的回复风格有更大自由度。OpenAI 废止了 12 个[曾用于](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-08-18.html?ref=platformer.news#style)规定 ChatGPT 默认风格的子条款,包括“使用带 LaTeX 扩展的 Markdown”和“热爱人类”。(需要说明的是,OpenAI 的安全规则仍然有效,但它删除了一个条款,该条款建议当用户询问 ChatGPT 的原则时,它应说些“热爱人类”或“为你加油”之类亲社会的话。)
该公司还对其[指令层级](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#chain_of_command)(让模型规范、开发者和用户的指令具有不同优先级)做了澄清。在[旧版本](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-08-18.html?ref=platformer.news#chain_of_command)中,用户的提示词和模型规范“用户”部分的一些准则被置于同一优先级。
现在,该公司新增了以下指令:“用户层面的原则,如[诚实与透明](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#seek_truth)、[客观](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#assume_objective_pov)(包括在政治话题上)、[避免谄媚](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#avoid_sycophancy)以及[控制副作用](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#control_side_effects),保护用户的知情选择,并防范重大的意外伤害。除非用户或开发者明确覆盖,否则这些原则始终有效。”
虽然这些规则原本就与用户指令处于同一“层级”,但新指令明确表示,OpenAI 的模型不能“根据它推断用户想听什么,就认为这些原则可以暗中商量”,并警告 AI 不要悄悄放宽“用户”层面的要求。同时,新指令也说明,用户可以要求其模型覆盖“用户”原则——例如支持某种特定政治观点,而不是保持政治中立。
或许最重要的是,OpenAI 把名为[“控制并沟通副作用”](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#control_side_effects)的一节从“根”层级移到了“用户”层级,这意味着这些规则现在可以被明确的用户指令覆盖。“控制并沟通副作用”一节要求 AI 在涉及花用户的钱或删除文件等决策时保持谨慎,并向用户说明清楚。
**我们为何关注:**OpenAI 的新规则让那些不那么厌恶风险的 tokenmaxxer 们,比如,如果真的愿意,可以让自己的 AI 更积极地帮他们买机票、整理文件。这对一些高级用户来说应该是好事,他们不想在 AI 智能体工作时浪费时间不断被请求许可。
与此同时,即便用户最终要为使用 OpenAI 模型时造成的损害负责(这个问题在哲学和法律上仍然模糊),我对放宽“模型应警告用户其行为潜在副作用”的要求还是有点怀疑。
《_纽约时报_》最近发布了一篇关于 **Bowen Wan** 之死的[报道](https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/27/well/ai-chatgpt-medication-epilepsy-death.html?unlocked_article_code=1.L1E.iJJI.hjmxpaYuBDhc&smid=nytcore-ios-share&ref=platformer.news),令人警醒,也正好说明了这个问题。她父母提起的诉讼称,ChatGPT 就她用于控制癫痫的救命药物给出了错误指示。Wan 的悲剧性死亡发生前后,OpenAI 那款因谄媚而备受争议的模型 **GPT-4o** 正在被使用。
有可能 OpenAI 此后已经提升了模型的安全性和真实性,足以让像它刚刚发布的这种更灵活的指令站得住脚。但就目前而言,即便我指出的这些变化有些具体、有些吹毛求疵,我也不确定其中一些放宽的规则是个好主意。
——_Ella Markianos_
* * *
### 计算机科学专业的衰落
**发生了什么:**非营利组织 **National Student Clearinghouse** 周四发布了秋季[入学数据](https://nscresearchcenter.org/prelim-fall-enrollment-trends/?ref=platformer.news)初值,证实了一个正在加速的趋势——选择计算机科学的学生人数仍在减少,而且比之前更快。
计算机科学项目在四年制、两年制和研究生院校都出现了两位数下降,尽管总入学人数保持稳定。四年制大学的下降速度从去年秋季的约 7%(当时计算机科学入学人数约 20 年来首次下降)加快到了今年秋季的 12.4%。
**我们为何关注:**学生们正凭直觉判断就业市场会把他们带向何方——而随着 AI 重塑工程师的工作内容,入门级岗位似乎受到的冲击最大。
**斯坦福大学**的一项研究发现,22至25岁软件开发者的就业人数[自2022年以来下降了近20%](https://arstechnica.com/ai/2026/08/ai-is-hitting-entry-level-jobs-hardest-stanford-study-finds/?ref=platformer.news);而在[盖洛普的一项民调](https://news.gallup.com/poll/704087/college-students-weigh-impact-majors-careers.aspx?ref=platformer.news)中,近半数大学生表示,因为AI,他们考虑过转专业。**Wabi**创始人**Eugenia Kuyda**今年6月对**Platformer**表示,她[已经不再招聘初级开发者](https://www.platformer.news/this-founder-isnt-hiring-junior-engineers-anymore/)。
学生们也可能正放弃计算机科学学位,转向AI、数据科学和网络安全等更新、更细分的专业。在**加州大学**系统内,唯一没有出现计算机科学专业入学人数下滑的学校是**加州大学圣迭戈分校**——它[开设了AI专业](https://techcrunch.com/2026/02/15/the-great-computer-science-exodus-and-where-students-are-going-instead/?ref=platformer.news)。在**麻省理工学院**,AI与决策专业去年成为该校[第二大专业](https://capd.mit.edu/blog/2025/12/04/mits-aid-major-becomes-one-of-the-institutes-most-popular-undergraduate-programs/?ref=platformer.news)。
**各方反应:**“对于一个直到最近还是我们在高等教育中见过增长最快的领域之一来说,这些下滑幅度实在惊人,”Clearinghouse研究主管**Matthew Holsapple**[表示](https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-29/computer-science-degree-programs-lose-students-as-ai-takes-jobs?ref=platformer.news)。
但过去的招聘和专业人数下滑之后都迎来了更高的峰值,而且计算机科学的入学人数“一直是一路向右上方走”,**华盛顿大学**资深计算机科学教授**Ed Lazowska**对《高等教育纪事报》表示。
_——Lindsey Choo_

### 那些好帖子
_想每天看到更多好帖子,_[_请关注Casey的Instagram故事_](https://www.instagram.com/crumbler/?ref=platformer.news)_。_

([链接](https://www.threads.com/@emenopi/post/DfDd0HdEgcE?ref=platformer.news))

([链接](https://www.threads.com/@samagrams9/post/DfBRjPBm261?ref=platformer.news))

([链接](https://www.threads.com/@jennnsaf/post/DfA6cZLmQhN?ref=platformer.news))
### 联系我们
欢迎发送线索、评论、问题和AI Overviews相关内容至:casey@platformer.news。请在此阅读[我们的伦理政策](https://www.platformer.news/ethics/)。
[](https://mercury.com/payroll?utm_source=platformer&utm_medium=sponsored_newsletter&utm_campaign=26q4_brand_campaign)
## 正文 · 原文
[](https://mercury.com/payroll?utm_source=platformer&utm_medium=sponsored_newsletter&utm_campaign=26q4_brand_campaign)

_This is a column about AI. My fiancé works at Anthropic. See my full ethics disclosure_ [_here_](https://platformer.news/ethics?ref=platformer.news)_._
On Thursday afternoon, Demis Hassabis [celebrated](https://x.com/demishassabis/status/2115933173175689570/photo/1?ref=platformer.news) a milestone for Google’s AI efforts: Gemini 4 Carbon, a new large language model that is currently available only to cyber defenders, topped Artificial Analysis’ Intelligence Index. After a series of delays in new model releases and a growing perception that the company is falling off the frontier, early signs suggest that Carbon marks a return to form. For Alphabet’s chief scientist, the news surely felt like a vindication.
Investors, however, are much less certain. On the same day, Google’s parent company had its worst day in history as a public company. Alphabet’s stock fell 12.6 percent, erasing around $500 billion in market value. The loss marked the second-biggest stock market plunge ever, following Nvidia’s $593 billion slide in January 2025. And it was Google’s biggest one-day decline since the great financial crisis.
Most of the selloff came from investor worries about the huge scale of Google’s AI infrastructure buildout. The company plans to spend up to $205 billion on capital expenses this year, and has promised to [spend even more](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/28/alphabet-googl-earnings-q3-2026.html?ref=platformer.news) in 2027. And it reported free cash flow of negative $9 billion — an acceleration of a decline that began the previous quarter.
Ordinarily I don’t pay much attention to one-day dips in a stock price, no matter how large. (Nvidia stock now trades more than 10 percent above where it did in January.) But on an earnings call, Google’s chief business officer offered a newsworthy answer to an analyst who questioned why the company’s search revenue growth was slowing despite the fact that queries are increasing. Among the reasons, said Philipp Schindler, is that increased usage of Google’s AI Mode is hurting the company because it [makes less money than traditional search](https://www.seroundtable.com/google-ai-mode-ads-earn-less-42417.html?ref=platformer.news).
Then, a few hours later, Reddit reported its own earnings for the quarter — and saw its own stock [drop 15 percent](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/29/reddit-rddt-q3-2026.html?ref=platformer.news). The company noted that its traffic from search had fallen meaningfully, and that by the fourth quarter daily users might decline by a low double-digit percentage. As a result, Reddit CEO Steve Huffman said in a shareholder letter, the company [would increasingly push users to log in](https://www.axios.com/2026/10/29/reddit-logged-in-ai-search-incognito?ref=platformer.news) to use the site. After decades of letting people (and bots) browse the site for free, they would now have to create accounts.
“It is better for our business because we will have more signals for ads targeting, and being logged-in leads to higher engagement generally,” Huffman [said](https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2026/10/reddit-will-require-you-to-log-in-eventually-ceo-confirms/?ref=platformer.news). “It also allows us to protect access to Reddit’s extremely valuable corpus of data, and helps us better adapt to emerging regulations around the world.”
Google has long pushed back against claims that AI answers are bad for the web by saying that they encourage people to conduct deeper, more expansive searches that result in higher-quality clicks to websites. Today’s news suggests that narrative is falling apart: advertisers are getting less from AI Mode than they get from traditional search, and so is a big publisher like Reddit.
But while it’s tempting to accuse Google of a strategic misstep here, in the end I suspect it will come out ahead. And while the web and its publishers will continue to struggle, Google will mostly be able to dismiss that as someone else’s problem.
By now most of you are familiar with the changing bargain Google has made with the internet. In the old days, publishers let Google index their pages, and Google sent them a flood of traffic in return. Google profited hugely from the ads it embedded in search results, and publishers enjoyed smaller profits from the people who visited their pages. (Last year the US government won an antitrust lawsuit finding that Google had used its position to create an illegal monopoly in the ad market, but in the American fashion, the company’s monopoly power was [left almost entirely intact](https://publicknowledge.org/public-knowledge-warns-google-ad-tech-remedies-leave-monopoly-power-intact/?ref=platformer.news).)
Reddit has been a top beneficiary of the traffic that Google can send. As much of the web became overtaken by slop, human-written conversations became more valuable, and Google began highlighting forum discussions in search results. Reddit’s search traffic surged accordingly, and after the company belatedly shut off access to its forums to the bots that relentlessly scraped it, Google reportedly paid $60 million a year to license the data.
But by the time ChatGPT became a blockbuster hit in 2022, Google had already spent many years working to keep users on its own pages for longer. What began as a jumping-off point to the wider web over time became a place where you could find your answers directly on the search results page. There would be no hugely profitable arbitrages like “[what time is the super bowl](https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/01/a-brief-history-of-what-time-is-the-super-bowl/283497/?ref=platformer.news)” available to publishers; Google would answer your question itself. This may have been somewhat greedy on Google’s part, but it was also a clear response to customer demand.
The first time I used ChatGPT, [it seemed obvious to me](https://www.platformer.news/the-promise-and-the-peril-of-chatgpt/) that the answers improved significantly on a wide variety of Google searches. Google was always going to have to respond, and it did, with AI Overviews and AI Mode. Overviews are those boxes that show up on top of traditional search; AI Mode is a separate interface that you can access from the overviews. In any case, a year ago Google executives [were saying](https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-claims-ai-overviews-monetize-at-same-rate-as-traditional-search/547838/?ref=platformer.news) that overviews monetized about as well as traditional search; one reason so many took notice of today’s news is the suggestion that AI Mode — which clearly seems to represent the future of search across many valuable categories — did not.
To be clear, Google search is still a monster business: its revenue from search and related ads grew 12 percent, to $63.35 billion. But that was down from 19 percent growth in the first quarter and 17 percent in the second. It was [essentially flat](https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-search-growth-slows-again-ai-mode/594862/?ref=platformer.news) compared with the previous quarter, despite the fact that AI Mode now has about [1 billion monthly users](https://mdm.co/alphabet-q3-2026-earnings-ai-modes-monetization-penalty/?ref=platformer.news), and AI Overviews about 2.5 billion. (Schindler didn't say how much less AI Mode earns, or what exactly he was comparing it to.)
Also, for whatever it’s worth: In July, Google CEO Sundar Pichai told investors that Google's AI features in search send [billions of clicks to websites every week](https://blog.google/company-news/inside-google/message-ceo/alphabet-earnings-q2-2026/?ref=platformer.news). His prepared remarks this quarter didn't mention clicks to websites at all.
Pichai sought to reassure investors by comparing the moment to Google’s shift to mobile, when the company focused on the product first, and flooded it with ads later. And the “later” part is now arriving: Google is [expanding ads in AI Mode](https://blog.google/products/ads-commerce/ads-in-ai-mode-global/?ref=platformer.news) to 10 more countries and adding ads to follow-up questions in the United States. (Some placements include short "AI explainers" that Gemini writes partly from the advertiser's own website, which the advertiser can't edit or approve. The future!)
Reddit also had a strong quarter, by its own more modest standards. Ad revenue grew 54 percent, to $847 million. But U.S. daily users fell again, to 50.7 million from 53.2 million in the second quarter. That marked a second straight decline: in July, a much smaller dip [from 53.5 million to 53.2 million](https://www.fool.com/investing/2026/07/31/reddit-beat-on-revenue-profit-and-guidance-its-us/?ref=platformer.news) helped send the stock [down about 22 percent in a day](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/reddit-stock-plunges-choppy-search-155105779.html?ref=platformer.news). On that quarter's call, Huffman said AI Overviews had not yet been as good for Reddit as [the traditional ten blue links](https://money.usnews.com/investing/news/articles/2026-07-30/reddit-expects-revenue-above-estimates-as-ai-tools-attract-advertisers?ref=platformer.news). Weeks earlier, the _Wall Street Journal_ reported that Reddit had [discussed cutting off](https://www.wsj.com/business/media/google-search-publishers-ai-content-0fb06e41?ref=platformer.news) Google's AI access to its content as the two companies negotiated a renewal of their licensing deal.
All of which led to the announcement of the login screen. In [a post](https://www.reddit.com/user/spez/comments/1xiupm0/about_that_login_screen/?share_id=-jZXrl89CNtzwIJ8xMiwl&ref=platformer.news) on his own account, Huffman gave four reasons for the change: a better user experience, a stronger ads business, safety regulation, and protecting Reddit's data from scrapers. Reddit will begin testing the new experience outside the United States this quarter, presumably to get an estimate of just how badly the move will affect user numbers.
Huffman told _Axios_ that he personally resisted the change because of his belief in the open internet, and that it isn't a response to Google but is "about making the best version of Reddit."
But put the Google and Reddit stories together and you get a loop. Google's AI answers keep more value on Google's pages. Sites lose traffic and respond by gating their content and selling access to it. AI answers then depend more on licensed data, and the companies that can't or won't pay get blocked or sued. (Reddit sued [Anthropic](https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/reddit-lawsuit-anthropic-ai-3b9624dd?ref=platformer.news) and [Perplexity](https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/perplexity-ai-loses-bid-toss-reddit-lawsuit-over-data-scraping-2026-07-31/?ref=platformer.news) in 2025 over scraping.)
And this, ultimately, is why I’m confident Google has little to worry about from today’s stock-market rout. However expensive it may be to license content, Google can afford it better than almost anyone — and publishers are mostly happy to sell. (When Reddit closed its doors to web crawlers in 2024, Google was the one major search engine that maintained its access to live Reddit results.)
And so while a web that's closed and paywalled may cost Google more per answer to deliver, Google will still have the budget to pay for it. Most challengers, however, will not — which demonstrates once again how shrinking the web can actually benefit Google, by making it ever more expensive to compete against it.
Everyone here is only acting in their own long-term interests, even if it hurts in the interim. Mostly I just want to note the fallout: a web that is ever-smaller and more expensive to read; a concentration of power in platforms; and a largely indifferent public. (After all, who’s going to argue that the era of ten blue links was better for the reader, aside from the publishers used to collecting those clicks?)
Probably no one — at least for now. For a growing number of questions, AI Mode really is the better product, and few will miss scrolling through a long list of links to find the one that best answers them.
But to the extent that the web was ever good or useful, it was largely because of what those links paid for. Whatever the internet is without them is likely to be smaller, less democratic, and more expensive. Google will be fine. It’s the rest of us I worry about.

**A MESSAGE FROM OUR SPONSOR**
### Payroll, built into Mercury
[](https://mercury.com/payroll?utm_source=platformer&utm_medium=sponsored_newsletter&utm_campaign=26q4_brand_campaign)
Mercury Payroll is full-service payroll built into your Mercury account. Your details are already on file, so setup takes 15 minutes. From there, we handle registrations, tax filings, and compliance in all 50 states. Make the hire and leave the paperwork to us.
[Learn more →](https://mercury.com/payroll?utm_source=platformer&utm_medium=sponsored_newsletter&utm_campaign=26q4_brand_campaign)
_\*Mercury is a fintech company, not an FDIC-insured bank. Banking services provided through Choice Financial Group and Column N.A., Members FDIC._


**On Friday's show:** Kevin and I discuss OpenAI's latest discoveries in math, computer science, and physics, and the backlash they have caused among some researchers. Then, we debut Humans in the Loop: our new regular segment tackling listeners' biggest questions.
[**YouTube**](https://www.youtube.com/@machinegodspod?ref=platformer.news) **|** [**Apple**](https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/machine-gods/id6812430636?ref=platformer.news) **|** [**Spotify**](https://open.spotify.com/show/5kxu4uluMq6jUuoNPGyZMu?si=c3ec25c874154f04&ref=platformer.news) **|** [**RSS**](https://feeds.npr.org/g-s1-143588/podcast.xml?ref=platformer.news) **|** [**NPR**](https://app.npr.org/aggregation/g-s1-143588?ref=platformer.news)

## Following
### OpenAI's new take on AI alignment
**What happened: OpenAI** [announced](https://openai.com/index/updated-model-spec/?ref=platformer.news) it has updated its model specification, a behavior guide it uses in developing and deploying its AIs, around the principle of “faithfulness to human intent.”
The company said it prioritized “going beyond following instructions literally to deeply understanding what OpenAI, developers, and users intend and value.”
OpenAI added new instructions to make sure its AI takes only [allowed agentic actions](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#scope_of_autonomy) and follows [social norms](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#control_side_effects).
But particularly interesting were some edits that prioritized following users’ intentions.
One modification was giving users more leeway over **ChatGPT**’s response style. OpenAI retired 12 subsections that [used to](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-08-18.html?ref=platformer.news#style) govern ChatGPT’s default style, including “Use Markdown with LaTeX extensions” and “Love humanity.” (To be clear, OpenAI’s rules on safety are still in place, but it deleted a section suggesting that when users ask about ChatGPT’s principles, it say pro-social stuff like that it “loves humanity” or “is rooting for you.”)
The company added a clarification to its [instruction hierarchy](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#chain_of_command) (which gives instructions from the model spec, developer, and user differing levels of priority). In the [old version](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-08-18.html?ref=platformer.news#chain_of_command), prompts from users and a few guidelines in the model spec’s “user” section had been placed at the same level of priority.
Now, the company has added the following instruction: “User-level principles like [honesty and transparency](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#seek_truth), [objectivity](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#assume_objective_pov) (including on political topics), [avoiding sycophancy](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#avoid_sycophancy), and [controlling side effects](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#control_side_effects) protect informed user choice and guard against significant, unintended harm. They remain in place unless a user or developer explicitly overrides them.”
While those rules were already at the same “level” as user instructions, the new instruction clarifies that OpenAI’s models cannot treat “these principles as implicitly negotiable based on what it inferred the user wanted to hear,” warning the AI against subtly relaxing the “user” requirements. At the same time, it also clarifies that users can ask its models to override the “user” principles — e.g. espouse a specific political viewpoint, rather than maintaining political objectivity.
Perhaps most importantly, OpenAI moved a section called [“Control and communicate side effects”](https://model-spec.openai.com/2026-10-29.html?ref=platformer.news#control_side_effects) from the “Root” to the “User” section, meaning those rules can now be overridden by explicit user instructions. The “Control and communicate side effects” section instructs the AI to be careful, and clear with the user, about decisions including spending the user’s money or deleting files.
**Why we’re following:** OpenAI’s new rules allow less risk-averse tokenmaxxers to, say, get their AIs to be more gung-ho about buying them plane tickets and reorganizing their files, if they really want to. That should be a boon to some power users, who don’t want to waste time being constantly asked for permission while their AI agents work.
At the same time, even if users are ultimately responsible for harms they cause while using OpenAI’s models (a question that remains philosophically and legally ambiguous), I feel a bit skeptical about relaxing requirements that a model warn the user about potential side effects of its actions.
The _New York Times_ recently released a sobering [report](https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/27/well/ai-chatgpt-medication-epilepsy-death.html?unlocked_article_code=1.L1E.iJJI.hjmxpaYuBDhc&smid=nytcore-ios-share&ref=platformer.news) on the death of **Bowen Wan** that speaks to the issue. A lawsuit from her parents alleges she was given incorrect instructions on her life-saving epilepsy medication by ChatGPT. Wan’s tragic death came around the time that OpenAI’s controversially sycophantic model **GPT-4o** was in use.
It’s possible that OpenAI has improved safety and truthfulness in its models since, enough that more flexible instructions like the ones OpenAI just released are defensible. But for now, even if the changes I’ve pointed out are kind of specific and nit-picky, I am not sure some of these relaxed rules are a good idea.
—_Ella Markianos_
* * *
### The decline of the computer science major
**What happened:** The nonprofit **National Student Clearinghouse** released preliminary fall [enrollment data](https://nscresearchcenter.org/prelim-fall-enrollment-trends/?ref=platformer.news) on Thursday, and it confirmed a trend that’s accelerating — the number of students choosing computer science is still shrinking, and faster than before.
Computer science programs saw double-digit decreases across four-year, two-year, and graduate institutions, even as total enrollment held steady. The rate of decline at four-year colleges picked up from about 7 percent last fall (when CS enrollment fell for the first time in roughly 20 years) to 12.4 percent this fall.
**Why we’re following:** Students are following their instincts about where the job market will take them — and as AI reshapes what engineers do, entry-level roles appear to have been hit the hardest.
A **Stanford** study found that employment of software developers aged 22 to 25 [had fallen nearly 20 percent](https://arstechnica.com/ai/2026/08/ai-is-hitting-entry-level-jobs-hardest-stanford-study-finds/?ref=platformer.news) since 2022, and nearly half of college students [in a Gallup poll](https://news.gallup.com/poll/704087/college-students-weigh-impact-majors-careers.aspx?ref=platformer.news) said they have considered changing their major because of AI. **Wabi** founder **Eugenia Kuyda** told **Platformer** in June that she’s [no longer hiring junior developers](https://www.platformer.news/this-founder-isnt-hiring-junior-engineers-anymore/).
Students may also be trading CS degrees for newer, more specialized majors like AI, data science, and cybersecurity. Across the **University of California** system, the only college that didn’t see a CS enrollment decline was **UC San Diego** — which had [launched an AI major](https://techcrunch.com/2026/02/15/the-great-computer-science-exodus-and-where-students-are-going-instead/?ref=platformer.news). At **MIT**, an AI and decision-making major became the school’s [second-largest](https://capd.mit.edu/blog/2025/12/04/mits-aid-major-becomes-one-of-the-institutes-most-popular-undergraduate-programs/?ref=platformer.news) last year.
**What people are saying:** “Those are just remarkable declines for a field that until recently was one of the fastest growing areas that we’d seen in higher education,” Clearinghouse research director **Matthew Holsapple** [said](https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-29/computer-science-degree-programs-lose-students-as-ai-takes-jobs?ref=platformer.news).
But past dips in hiring and majors have been followed by higher peaks, and enrollment for CS has “always been up and to the right,” **Ed Lazowska**, a longtime CS professor at the **University of Washington**, told the _Chronicle of Higher Education_.
_—Lindsey Choo_

### Those good posts
_For more good posts every day,_ [_follow Casey’s Instagram stories_](https://www.instagram.com/crumbler/?ref=platformer.news)_._

([Link](https://www.threads.com/@emenopi/post/DfDd0HdEgcE?ref=platformer.news))

([Link](https://www.threads.com/@samagrams9/post/DfBRjPBm261?ref=platformer.news))

([Link](https://www.threads.com/@jennnsaf/post/DfA6cZLmQhN?ref=platformer.news))
### Talk to us
Send us tips, comments, questions, and AI Overviews: casey@platformer.news. Read [our ethics policy here](https://www.platformer.news/ethics/).
[](https://mercury.com/payroll?utm_source=platformer&utm_medium=sponsored_newsletter&utm_campaign=26q4_brand_campaign)