OpenAI 汇编各方法庭之友意见,主张 AI 训练应适用合理使用原则

来源:OpenAI:官网动态(RSS · 排除企业/客户案例) 2026年10月30日 08:00 AIHOT 评分:62 精选
摘要:OpenAI 整理了在《纽约时报》诉讼中提交给法院的多份支持合理使用的法庭之友意见摘要,作者包括图书馆协会、法律学者、独立创作者和美国政府等。各意见书主张 AI 训练具有转换性、不构成版权法认可的市场损害,并警告限缩合理使用将阻碍科研进展与美国经济繁荣;完整文件可在法院公开卷宗查阅。
推荐理由:OpenAI 汇编多领域法庭之友意见,读者可据此了解 AI 训练合理使用抗辩的核心论点与《纽约时报》诉讼的争议焦点。
# OpenAI 汇编各方法庭之友意见,主张 AI 训练应适用合理使用原则 > 原标题:Fair use benefits everyone - 来源:OpenAI:官网动态 - 发布时间:2026-10-30T00:00:00.000Z - AIHOT:https://aihot.news/items/oas684tt9kpeds9cq7vgjvo1x - 原文:https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone ## 摘要 OpenAI 整理了在《纽约时报》诉讼中提交给法院的多份支持合理使用的法庭之友意见摘要,作者包括图书馆协会、法律学者、独立创作者和美国政府等。各意见书主张 AI 训练具有转换性、不构成版权法认可的市场损害,并警告限缩合理使用将阻碍科研进展与美国经济繁荣;完整文件可在法院公开卷宗查阅。 ## 推荐理由 OpenAI 汇编多领域法庭之友意见,读者可据此了解 AI 训练合理使用抗辩的核心论点与《纽约时报》诉讼的争议焦点。 ## 正文 · 中文译文 ## 合理使用惠及所有人 作者、记者、创作者、学者、无障碍倡导者、法律专家、图书馆员、经济学家和企业领袖纷纷发声,支持合理使用这一由来已久的原则,以及该原则在 AI 训练中的适用。 分享 几十年来,合理使用在推动惠及所有人的创新方面发挥了关键作用。它促成了重要的医学和科学突破,也催生了新技术,为无数人——包括作者和记者——带来了实实在在的积极改变。与此同时,[《纽约时报》的诉讼](https://openai.com/new-york-times/)却要求所有人无视半个世纪的法律历史与进步,为了自己狭隘的一己之利——一笔本不该得的赔偿——抛弃合理使用这一由来已久的原则。 来自广泛领域的专家和领袖已经认识到,合理使用是一种双赢,惠及所有人;他们向法院提交了支持合理使用的意见书,阐述了自己的观点。 下面摘录了其中部分意见书的内容,均按原文呈现。完整的提交文件可在公开的法院案卷中查阅,你也可以[在这里](https://openai.com/new-york-times/)进一步了解合理使用与 AI。 - [AI 进展⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-ai-progress-heading) - [美国盲人理事会、研究图书馆协会、美国图书馆协会、消费者技术协会 & 商业软件联盟⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-acb-cta-bsa-heading) - [作者联盟⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-authors-alliance-heading) - [Engine 与开发者联盟⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-engine-heading) - [美国创新基金会⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-foundation-for-american-innovation-heading) - [Joshua S. Gans⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-joshua-s-gans-heading) - [Kevin Kelly⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-kevin-kelly-and-aaron-black-heading) - [Matthew Sag⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-matthew-sag-heading) - [Michael Wall 与 Sarah Rose Siskind⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-michael-wall-and-sarah-rose-siskind-heading) - [Public Knowledge⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-public-knowledge-heading) - [Ron Suskind 与 Brian L. Frye⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-ron-suskind-and-brian-frye-heading) - [美国政府⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-united-states-government-heading) #### AI 进展 法院应当驳回原告试图将版权延伸至既定边界之外的请求。AI 训练对受版权保护作品的使用目的截然不同,不会向公众提供这些作品的替代性获取途径,也不会造成《版权法》所认定的市场损害。相反,它催生了一系列广泛的变革性技术,这些技术已经在带来公共利益。版权的存在是为了促进创造力和进步,而不是压制合法创新,也不是保护作者免受竞争。因此,既定的合理使用原则必然得出这样的结论:生成式 AI 训练属于合理使用。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-ai-progress-heading) #### 美国盲人理事会、研究图书馆协会、美国图书馆协会、消费者技术协会 & 商业软件联盟 本案涉及的远不止开发大语言模型(LLM)的公司。它关系到医学研究人员和患者,关系到为有不同学习需求的学生提供服务的教育工作者,关系到寻求更大独立性的残障人士,关系到运用农业知识的农民,关系到探索新表达形式的独立创作者,也关系到从软件到法律等各个行业。这些群体有一个共同利益:能够研究和学习广泛而多样的知识来源,并能获得让这种学习发挥作用的工具。许多人依赖他人开发的系统(包括开源 AI 系统),而不是自己训练模型。合理使用支撑着他们学习、发现、交流和创造的能力。限制对合理使用作品的训练,既会影响构建 AI 的机构,也会影响使用 AI 的人。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-acb-cta-bsa-heading) #### 作者联盟 市场稀释理论要求版权法保护权利人免受一种它此前从未限制过的经济现象的影响。新作品可能降低旧作品的销量、曝光度或价值,却并未复制其受保护的表达。《版权法》有意将这种竞争置于版权人的控制之外。因此,法庭之友恳请法院裁定:“市场稀释”,即来自非侵权输出的总体竞争压力——包括那些占据相同主题或体裁、具有相同不受保护特征或争夺相同受众的输出——不属于《美国法典》第17编第107条第4款意义上的可认知市场损害。驳回该理论将维护第二巡回法院一贯坚持的区分:版权保护作者免受对其受保护表达的替代,而非免受仅仅与之竞争的新表达的成功。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-authors-alliance-heading) #### 引擎与开发者联盟 初创公司对基础模型的使用表明,使用受版权保护的作品训练AI模型属于合理使用,而非版权侵权。训练基础模型的目的是构建一个通用工具,供他人适配新用途,而非复制其学习到的作品。初创公司所选择的用途与任何训练数据集中作品的用途毫无相似之处。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-engine-heading) #### 美国创新基金会 在AI训练能够创造新知识、表达、软件及其他能力的范围内,这些益处会影响第四要素对使用市场影响的评估。这一推理支持在此处的一种新颖应用:考虑那些能够实现新分析、软件及其他生产性工作的能力所具有的国家安全价值。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-foundation-for-american-innovation-heading) #### Joshua S. Gans _战略管理教授_ 版权不仅支持创作内容的激励,也支持构建从这些内容中学习的工具的激励;而一项将每一次被替代的销售都视为可诉的规则,可能削弱后者,却无法可靠地保护前者。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-joshua-s-gans-heading) #### Kevin Kelly _作者_ AI 是一项变革性技术,能加速艺术与科学无数学科中新作品的创作。Kelly 先生对 AI 如何推动文学领域发展有切身体会。在他看来,每个 AI 模型都可以理解为一个全新的媒介,让作者有能力创作新的文本和思想,并进行推理。因此,若在合理使用问题上判原告胜诉,给予原告的将远远超出国会意图赋予其原创表达的有限垄断权。这会阻碍能够传播前所未有海量信息的技术的发展,也会妨碍新的思维模式以及艺术与科学领域新原创作品的创作。法庭之友提交本意见书,支持被告的论点,即为训练大语言模型而使用受版权保护的作品属于 17 U.S.C. § 107 下的合理使用。基于他毕生从事写作的经历,版权所有者获得的保护对 Kelly 先生很重要。同样至关重要的是,为版权材料的允许使用和变革性技术的发展保留空间。否则,版权将扼杀它本应鼓励的创造力、创新和知识传播。合理使用原则对于确保这种平衡至关重要。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-kevin-kelly-and-aaron-black-heading) #### Matthew Sag _法学教授_ 根据本案记录,被告使用原告作品进行 AI 训练具有高度转换性,强烈支持认定合理使用,因为在现实条件下,被告模型的输出与训练过程中产生的不可见中间副本在任何相关方面都不相似。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-matthew-sag-heading) #### Michael Wall 和 Sarah Rose Siskind _音乐家兼作曲家 / 喜剧演员兼作家_ 本意见书通过两位独立创作者的亲身经历,让人一窥这句话在实践中的含义——他们既依赖版权保护,_也_依赖 AI 工具来维持生计。_法庭之友_ Sarah Rose Siskind 和 Michael Wall 是创作并授权原创作品的艺术家。但他们用 AI 处理创作过程周边的工作,并在一个充斥着资源更雄厚竞争者的市场中发展自己的事业。对_法庭之友_而言,AI 并未取代创造力,也没有让他们走创作捷径。AI 帮助他们创作更多作品,并将作品延伸到新的表达形式。_法庭之友_的经历印证了美国的观点:AI 工具“能够也应该有助于拉平主流出版商与独立出版商之间的竞争环境”。Siskind 在业务的方方面面都用 AI,从日常行政事务到构思创意、招揽新客户。有了 AI,她的非创作工作更快、成本更低,创作工作也更好。用她的话说:“我觉得现在没有 AI,我的生意根本做不下去。”同样,AI 帮助 Wall 管理音乐业务的运营需求、降低成本,让他把更多时间投入作曲。和 Siskind 一样,他也怀疑没有 AI,自己的生意能否以目前的形式存续。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-michael-wall-and-sarah-rose-siskind-heading) #### Public Knowledge 合理使用制度保护了那些帮助人们在数字世界带来的海量信息中导航的工具,包括图片搜索和图书全文搜索。参见 Perfect 10, Inc. v. Amazon.com, Inc., 508 F.3d 1146, 1164–68 (9th Cir. 2007);Authors Guild v. Google, Inc., 804 F.3d 202, 216–17, 225 (2d Cir. 2015)(“Google Books”)。它同样保护了图书馆向有印刷阅读障碍的读者提供无障碍数字图书。参见 Authors Guild, Inc. v. HathiTrust, 755 F.3d 87, 101–03 (2d Cir. 2014)。它还保护了被纳入法律的技术标准的免费在线发布,认可“免费、便捷地获取法律所带来的重大公共利益”。Am. Soc’y for Testing & Materials v. Public.Resource.Org, Inc., 82 F.4th 1262, 1271–72 (D.C. Cir. 2023)。合理使用同样有助于确保 AI 的益处惠及广大公众,而不是被少数特权者所掌控。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-public-knowledge-heading) #### Ron Suskind 和 Brian L. Frye _普利策奖获奖记者 / 法学教授_ OpenAI 使用报纸文章训练其生成式 AI 模型,丝毫没有损害新闻原告合理的商业预期。他们委托撰写并出版报纸文章,期望向消费者出售这些文章的访问权。他们保留并继续行使向消费者出售文章访问权的专有权利。OpenAI 使用这些文章训练其 AI 模型,并未影响他们向消费者出售文章访问权的能力。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-ron-suskind-and-brian-frye-heading) #### 美国政府 在本案诉讼中,《纽约时报》试图限缩合理使用原则,将 OpenAI 大语言模型(LLM)的训练排除在外。这一结果将与版权法的基本原则相悖,并严重阻碍“科学与实用技艺的进步”。美国宪法第一条第 8 款第 8 项。如下文所述,包括独立媒体和初创媒体以及《纽约时报》本身在内的各类出版物,都在利用大语言模型服务于新闻及其他用途。而且,在本案争议标的之外,大语言模型已经在帮助各领域的研究人员取得重大突破。在误解合理使用原则的基础上限制大语言模型的发展,将阻碍此类创造性和科学进步,同时损害美国的繁荣与经济流动性。 [链接到本节](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-united-states-government-heading) - [2026](https://openai.com/news/?tags=2026) ## 作者 OpenAI ## 正文 · 原文 ## Fair use benefits everyone Authors, journalists, creators, academics, accessibility advocates, legal experts, librarians, economists and business leaders are voicing their support for the longstanding principle of fair use and its application to AI training. Share For decades, fair use has played a critical role in driving innovation that benefits everyone. It has helped deliver important medical and scientific breakthroughs and new technologies that have made real and positive differences for countless people, including authors and journalists. [The New York Times’ lawsuit](https://openai.com/new-york-times/), meanwhile, asks everyone to ignore a half century of legal history and progress, and toss aside the longstanding principle of fair use in their own narrow pursuit of an undeserved payday. Experts and leaders across a wide range of fields have recognized that fair use is a win-win that benefits everyone, and have shared their perspectives with the Court in filing briefs in support of fair use. Below you’ll find excerpts from some of those submissions, in their own words. The full filings are available on the public court docket, and you can read more about fair use and AI [here](https://openai.com/new-york-times/). - [AI Progress⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-ai-progress-heading) - [American Council of the Blind, Association of Research Libraries, American Library Association, Consumer Technology Association & Business Software Alliance⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-acb-cta-bsa-heading) - [Authors Alliance⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-authors-alliance-heading) - [Engine and Developers Alliance⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-engine-heading) - [Foundation for American Innovation⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-foundation-for-american-innovation-heading) - [Joshua S. Gans⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-joshua-s-gans-heading) - [Kevin Kelly⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-kevin-kelly-and-aaron-black-heading) - [Matthew Sag⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-matthew-sag-heading) - [Michael Wall and Sarah Rose Siskind⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-michael-wall-and-sarah-rose-siskind-heading) - [Public Knowledge⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-public-knowledge-heading) - [Ron Suskind and Brian L. Frye⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-ron-suskind-and-brian-frye-heading) - [United States Government⁠](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-united-states-government-heading) #### AI Progress The Court should reject Plaintiffs’ attempt to extend copyright beyond its established limits. AI training uses copyrighted works for a fundamentally different purpose, does not provide the public with substitute access to those works, and does not cause the market harm cognizable under the Copyright Act. Instead, it enables a broad array of transformative technologies that are already delivering public benefits. Copyright exists to promote creativity and progress, not to suppress lawful innovation or protect authors from competition. Settled fair use principles therefore compel the conclusion that generative AI training is fair use. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-ai-progress-heading) #### American Council of the Blind, Association of Research Libraries, American Library Association, Consumer Technology Association & Business Software Alliance This case concerns more than companies that develop large language models (LLMs). It affects medical researchers and patients, educators serving students with different learning needs, people with disabilities seeking greater independence, farmers applying agricultural knowledge, independent creators developing new forms of expression, and industry sectors from software to the law. These communities share an interest in the ability to study and learn from broad and diverse sources of knowledge, and in access to the tools that make that learning useful. Many depend on systems developed by others, including open source AI systems, rather than training models themselves. Fair use supports their ability to learn, discover, communicate, and create. Restrictions on fair use training would affect both the institutions building AI and the people using it. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-acb-cta-bsa-heading) #### Authors Alliance The market dilution theory asks copyright law to protect rightsholders against an economic phenomenon that it has never restricted before. New works can reduce the sales, visibility, or value of older works without copying their protected expression. The Copyright Act deliberately leaves that competition outside the copyright owner’s control. Amicus therefore respectfully asks the Court to hold that “market dilution,” i.e., aggregate competitive pressure from noninfringing outputs, including those that occupy the same subject matter or genre, that share unprotected characteristics, or compete for the same audience, is not cognizable market harm under 17 U.S.C. § 107(4). Rejecting the theory would preserve the distinction the Second Circuit has always maintained: copyright protects authors against substitution for their protected expression, not against the success of new expression that merely competes with it. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-authors-alliance-heading) #### Engine and Developers Alliance Startups’ use of foundation models demonstrates that using copyrighted works to train an AI model is a fair use, not copyright infringement. The purpose of training a foundation model is not to reproduce the works it learns; it is to build a general-purpose tool that others can adapt to new ends. The ends startups have chosen bear no resemblance to the purposes of the works in any training dataset. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-engine-heading) #### Foundation for American Innovation To the extent AI training enables the creation of new knowledge, expression, software, and other capabilities, those benefits bear on factor four’s assessment of the use’s market effects. That reasoning supports a novel application here: considering the national-security value of capabilities that enable new analysis, software, and other productive work. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-foundation-for-american-innovation-heading) #### Joshua S. Gans _Professor of Strategic Management_ Copyright supports not only the incentive to create content but also the incentive to build tools that learn from that content, and a rule that treated every displaced sale as actionable can weaken the second without reliably protecting the first. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-joshua-s-gans-heading) #### Kevin Kelly _Author_ AI is a transformative technology that accelerates the creation of novel works across countless disciplines in the arts and sciences. Mr. Kelly has experience in how AI advances the field of literature. In his view, each AI model can be understood as an entirely new medium that offers authors the capability to create new texts and ideas, and to reason. A ruling for Plaintiffs on fair use would therefore grant Plaintiffs far more than the limited monopoly to their original expression Congress intended to confer. It would hinder the development of technologies capable of disseminating previously unimaginable quantities of information. It would also impede new modes of thought and the creation of new original works in both the arts and sciences. Amicus files this brief in support of Defendants’ argument that the use of copyrighted works to train large language models is a fair use under 17 U.S.C. § 107. Based on his lifelong pursuits of writing, the protections afforded to copyright owners are important to Mr. Kelly. Equally vital is preserving room for permissible uses of copyrighted material and the growth of transformative technologies. Otherwise, copyright will stifle the very creativity, innovation, and spread of knowledge it exists to encourage. The fair-use doctrine is critical to ensuring that balance. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-kevin-kelly-and-aaron-black-heading) #### Matthew Sag _Professor of Law_ On the record in this case, the defendants’ use of plaintiffs’ works for AI training is highly transformative and strongly favors a finding of fair use because under realistic conditions the outputs of defendants’ models are in no relevant way similar to the invisible intermediate copies made during the training process. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-matthew-sag-heading) #### Michael Wall and Sarah Rose Siskind _Musician and composer / comedian and writer_ This brief offers a window into what that sentence means in practice through the work of two independent creators who rely on copyright protection _and_ AI tools to sustain their livelihoods. _Amici_ Sarah Rose Siskind and Michael Wall are artists who create and license original works. But they use AI to handle work surrounding the creative process and to grow their businesses in a market teeming with better-resourced competitors. For _Amici_, AI does not displace creativity or shortcut their creative processes. AI helps them create more, and to extend their work into new modes of expression. _Amici_’s experience underscores the United States’ view that AI tools “can and should help level the playing field between mainstream and independent publishers.” Siskind uses AI in every aspect of her business, from day-to-day administrative tasks to developing ideas and bringing in new clients. With AI, her noncreative work is faster and less expensive, and her creative work is better. As she tells it, “I don’t think I could run my business without AI at this point.” Similarly, AI helps Wall manage the operational demands of his music business, reduce costs, and devote more of his time to composing music. Like Siskind, he doubts that his business could survive in its current form without AI. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-michael-wall-and-sarah-rose-siskind-heading) #### Public Knowledge Fair use has protected tools that help people navigate the vast collections of information the digital world has brought us, including image search and full-text book search. See Perfect 10, Inc. v. Amazon.com, Inc., 508 F.3d 1146, 1164–68 (9th Cir. 2007); Authors Guild v. Google, Inc., 804 F.3d 202, 216–17, 225 (2d Cir. 2015) (“Google Books”). It has also protected libraries’ provision of accessible digital books to readers with print disabilities. See Authors Guild, Inc. v. HathiTrust, 755 F.3d 87, 101–03 (2d Cir. 2014). And it has protected free online publication of technical standards incorporated into law, recognizing the “substantial public benefits of free and easy access to the law.” Am. Soc’y for Testing & Materials v. Public.Resource.Org, Inc., 82 F.4th 1262, 1271–72 (D.C. Cir. 2023). Fair use will be equally beneficial in ensuring that AI’s benefits accrue to the public at large, instead of being controlled by a privileged few. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-public-knowledge-heading) #### Ron Suskind and Brian L. Frye _Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist / Professor of Law_ OpenAI’s use of newspaper articles to train its generative AI models didn’t harm the reasonable commercial expectations of the News Plaintiffs in any way. They commissioned and published newspaper articles with the expectation of selling consumers access to those articles. They retain and continue to exercise the exclusive right to sell consumers access to their articles. Their ability to sell consumers access to their articles wasn’t affected by OpenAI’s use of those articles to train its AI models. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-ron-suskind-and-brian-frye-heading) #### United States Government In this litigation, the New York Times seeks to narrow fair-use doctrine to exclude the training of OpenAI’s large language models (LLMs). That result would be inconsistent with basic copyright law principles and severely hamper “the Progress of Science and useful Arts.” U.S. CONST. art. I, § 8, cl. 8. As discussed below, publications—including independent and start-up media, in addition to the New York Times itself—are leveraging LLMs for journalistic and other purposes. And beyond the subject matter of this litigation, LLMs are already helping researchers across fields achieve major breakthroughs. Constraining LLM development under a misunderstanding of fair use doctrine would thwart such creative and scientific progress while hindering American prosperity and economic mobility. [Link to this section](https://openai.com/index/fair-use-benefits-everyone/#fair-use-united-states-government-heading) - [2026](https://openai.com/news/?tags=2026) ## Author OpenAI