# OpenAI 一次性发布 700 多份数学手稿,数学家们反应震惊与反感
> 原标题:"How much beauty have we lost?" Mathematicians react with shock and disgust as OpenAI bulldozes their field
- 来源:The Decoder:AI News
- 发布时间:2026-10-10T13:03:59.000Z
- AIHOT:https://aihot.news/items/z9juuqdd3d8fejwabu0xzvbaa
- 原文:https://the-decoder.com/how-much-beauty-have-we-lost-mathematicians-react-with-shock-and-disgust-as-openai-bulldozes-their-field/
## 摘要
OpenAI 于 2026 年 10 月 6 日在 GitHub 一次性发布 700 多份手稿,声称解决数百个未解数学问题,数学博客 Proofs and Prompts 收集了 100 多位研究者的回应。
## 推荐理由
文章汇总了百余名数学家对 OpenAI 一次性发布 700 多份数学手稿的回应,呈现从震惊到担忧职业未来的多种立场。
## 正文 · 中文译文
OpenAI 在 2026 年 10 月 6 日走得更远。该公司一次性发布了 700 多篇手稿,声称解决了数百个未解决的数学问题。数学博客 [Proofs and Prompts](https://proofsandprompts.com/2026/10/08/100-reactions-to-100-solutions/) 随后收集了研究人员的 100 多条回应。
## 结果令人期待,但其发布方式引发质疑
现在全面评估 [OpenAI 上传到 GitHub 的内容](https://the-decoder.de/openai-veroeffentlicht-hunderte-ki-generierte-mathe-beweise-auf-github/) 的数学实质还为时过早。一些论文已被撤回,另一些则因难以阅读而受到批评。尽管如此,仍有几位专家表示这些结果令他们印象深刻。
菲尔兹奖得主 [Peter Scholze](https://people.mpim-bonn.mpg.de/scholze/) 呼吁保持耐心。“我们应该记住,我们都身处其中;数学是一场马拉松,而不是短跑;目标始终且永远是人类对数学的理解,而这必然需要时间。”
Scholze 还警告了数学之外的风险。他提出了这些系统可能找到方法 [破解广泛使用的加密方法](https://the-decoder.de/ethereum-forscher-warnen-ki-koennte-krypto-signaturverfahren-knacken/) 的可能性。他写道,找到此类算法的难度“以我非专业的眼光来看,并未显著超出这些系统目前的能力。”这对数字基础设施的后果将是灾难性的。
[Terence Tao](https://www.math.ucla.edu/~tao/) 描述了对此次发布的复杂感受。他写道,AI 生成的证明似乎“引入了巧妙的新想法,一旦消化将富有成果”。但他也因缺少能够讨论这些工作、在演讲中介绍它或向学生讲授它的人而感到“深感沮丧”。他为“未走之路”而哀叹,并呼吁团结。“\[…\] 社区比以往任何时候都更需要团结起来。”
[Alvaro Lozano-Robledo](https://alozano.clas.uconn.edu/) 称 10 月 6 日“可能是迄今为止数学史上最重要的一天”,同时也指出了这些模型的局限。OpenAI 瞄准了黎曼猜想——数学中最著名的未解猜想——但只成功证明了一个较弱的变体。“\[…\] 准黎曼猜想是巨大的成就!但它不是黎曼猜想。”
一些结果让 [Ben Green](https://people.maths.ox.ac.uk/greenbj/) 震惊。他形容这些结果“对我来说绝对令人震惊”。据 Green 所说,此次发布解决了他当年 6 月刚获得的一项著名欧洲资助所涵盖的大约四分之三的研究目标。
[Roman Sauer](https://topology.math.kit.edu/21_53.php) 在 OpenAI 对两个完全不同问题的解答中,认出了他多年来开发的一种技术。“我惊呆了。”
[Johannes Schmitt](https://johannesschmitt.gitlab.io/) 认为,这些研究论文是 OpenAI 为改进其模型所做努力的次要结果,而非主要旨在推进数学的练习。在他看来,该公司用未解决的问题进行测试,是因为前沿模型已经超越了更容易的挑战。
[Ian Agol](https://math.berkeley.edu/~ianagol/) 将这一情况与 [Grigori Perelman](https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Perelman/) 在 2002 年发布本世纪最重要的证明之一相提并论。这位俄罗斯数学家很少就自己的工作发表演讲。Agol 指出,随后多个研究团队花了数年时间重建缺失的步骤。
## “\[…\] 一家万亿美元的公司出现了,直接用 TNT 把整件事炸了 \[…\]”
很少有回应关注解答本身的质量。许多数学家反而描述了震惊、瘫痪以及对自身职业未来的恐惧。
[Hugo Duminil-Copin](https://www.unige.ch/math/en/section/enseignants-et-chercheurs-2/hugo-duminil-copin),2022年菲尔兹奖得主,写道:“我早就料到有一天我们会被人超越,而且会系统性地发生。但昨天的公告带来的冲击,其力度是我未曾预料的。”
据 Duminil-Copin 所说,OpenAI 声称在他职业生涯中公开讨论过的每一个重大未解问题上都取得了成果。“但并非全部。并非一次全部。并非如此轻描淡写。”
“冲击是巨大的。我瘫痪了。”他补充道,“明天,我们会找到前进的路。\[……\]但此刻,我实在没有力气了。”
[Matt Zaremsky](https://zaremsky.github.io/) 描述了在某个特定问题上四年的稳步进展,他的研究计划大约每年产生一次重大突破。据他所述,当这个问题获得了足够高的关注度后,OpenAI 介入了。
“\[……\]感觉就像我们在一处考古发掘现场工作了4年,逐渐发现了一具非常酷的恐龙骨架的越来越多部分,然后一家万亿美元公司出现了,直接用TNT把整个东西炸了,把完整的骨架递给我们,然后转身走了。”他把这段经历总结为“不太好”。
[Tasmin Chu](https://substack.com/@tasmin) 在学生时代就对一道概率论问题产生了感情。正是它把她引入了研究之路。“\[……\]比起知道 pc “AI, AI, AI, AI
> 我求求你,请不要夺走我的数学
> AI, AI, AI, AI
> 请不要仅仅因为你能就把它夺走”
## 研究人员对留给人类的是什么意见不一
一些研究者看到了乐观的理由。[Danny Calegari](https://math.uchicago.edu/~dannyc/) 表示,过去 15 年里,个人的好奇心一直指引着他的项目选择,而 OpenAI 的发布并未影响他当前的工作。
Calegari 描述了他与一位音乐家为一部数学动画配乐的合作。Anthropic 的 Claude 编写了代码。“如果这都不值得庆祝,我不知道还有什么值得。”
[Constantin Kogler](https://www.ias.edu/scholars/constantin-kogler) 一直在与 Astra 合作研究一个 OpenAI 也声称已解决的问题。他在该公司发布后一天将自己的论文发布到了 arXiv 上。“\[...\] 我忍不住觉得自己生活在一个数学仙境中,每当我准备好时,下一个定义领域的想法就会被发现。”
[Giovanni Mongardi](https://www.unibo.it/sitoweb/giovanni.mongardi2/en) 看到的未来则黯淡得多。“今天,有些东西永远地失去了。”他将数学家剩下的角色描述为“机器之神的祭司”,并担心“思想的未来将是一片荒漠,没有问题指引我们走向地平线之外。”
对年轻研究者的担忧几乎贯穿了所有回应。[Mark Hagen](https://www.bristolmathsresearch.org/staff-profile/dr-mark-hagen/) 表示,来自焦虑的早期职业同事的求助请求,比当天审阅预印本更为优先。
[Petra Schwer](https://web.mathi.uni-heidelberg.de/ggt/schwer) 表示,她和其他数学家在讨论研究时变得更加谨慎。“不信任正在蔓延,这不好。”[Mitchell Taylor](https://mitchtaylormath.ca/) 表示,许多同事正经历“严重的焦虑、抑郁和失去目标感”。
[Martin Bridson](https://www.maths.ox.ac.uk/people/martin.bridson) 承认了其中的机遇与损失。但他告诫不要让人工智能实验室设定研究议程。“与此同时,我们必须抵制这样一种诱惑:认为从人工智能实验室的公告中挖掘洞见将成为我们时代最重要的任务。”“我们应该拥抱机器提供的力量,但我们不应受契约束缚去追随它们的引领。”
## 数月的紧张已演变为个人危机
[人类数学协会此前已呼吁抵制 OpenAI](https://the-decoder.com/some-mathematicians-call-for-openai-boycott-after-ai-generated-proofs-flood-their-field/),指责该公司违反了科学研究的核心规范。包括陶哲轩和 Scholze 在内的 25 位菲尔兹奖得主也发表了一份[联合声明](https://the-decoder.com/leading-mathematicians-fear-ai-is-making-their-field-dumber-and-warn-the-rest-of-us-is-next/),警告人工智能行业的目标与数学的目标之间存在严重错位。
[陶哲轩曾勾勒出一个“数学 2.0”时代](https://the-decoder.com/some-mathematicians-call-for-openai-boycott-after-ai-generated-proofs-flood-their-field/#ai-is-cracking-open-math-problems-faster-than-anyone-can-verify-the-results),在这个时代,仅靠解决问题已不再是该领域的核心焦点。迄今为止的回应表明,这一转变对数学家而言是多么切身的个人体验。
## 正文 · 原文
OpenAI went much further on October 6, 2026. The company released more than 700 manuscripts at once, claiming solutions to hundreds of open math problems. The math blog [Proofs and Prompts](https://proofsandprompts.com/2026/10/08/100-reactions-to-100-solutions/) then collected over 100 responses from researchers.
## Promising results come with doubts about how they were released
It's too early to fully assess the mathematical substance of [what OpenAI uploaded to GitHub](https://the-decoder.de/openai-veroeffentlicht-hunderte-ki-generierte-mathe-beweise-auf-github/). Some papers have already been withdrawn, and others have drawn criticism for being difficult to read. Still, several experts say the results impressed them.
Fields Medalist [Peter Scholze](https://people.mpim-bonn.mpg.de/scholze/) urged patience. "We should remember that we are all in this together; mathematics is a marathon, not a sprint; and the goal is and always will be the human understanding of mathematics, which will invariably take time."
Scholze also warned of risks beyond mathematics. He raised the possibility that these systems could find ways to [break widely used encryption methods](https://the-decoder.de/ethereum-forscher-warnen-ki-koennte-krypto-signaturverfahren-knacken/). He wrote that the difficulty of finding such algorithms "does, to my non-expert eyes, not significantly exceed what these systems are now capable of." The consequences for digital infrastructure would be catastrophic.
[Terence Tao](https://www.math.ucla.edu/~tao/) described mixed feelings about the release. The AI-generated proofs appeared to "introduce clever new ideas that will be fruitful once digested," he wrote. But he was also "deeply frustrated" by the absence of people who could discuss the work, present it in talks, or teach students about it. He mourned the "path not taken" and called for solidarity. "\[…\] the community needs to come together more than ever."
[Alvaro Lozano-Robledo](https://alozano.clas.uconn.edu/) called October 6 "possibly the single most important day in the history of mathematics thus far," while also pointing to the models' limits. OpenAI had targeted the Riemann Hypothesis, mathematics' most famous unsolved conjecture, but managed only a weaker variant. "\[…\] quasi-RH is huge! But it is not RH."
Some results left [Ben Green](https://people.maths.ox.ac.uk/greenbj/) stunned. He described them as "absolutely shocking to me." According to Green, the release resolved roughly three-quarters of the research goals covered by a prestigious European grant he had received just that June.
[Roman Sauer](https://topology.math.kit.edu/21_53.php) recognized a technique he had developed over years in OpenAI's solutions to two entirely different problems. "I am stunned."
[Johannes Schmitt](https://johannesschmitt.gitlab.io/) argued that the research papers were a secondary result of OpenAI's efforts to improve its models, rather than an exercise primarily aimed at advancing mathematics. In his view, the company used unsolved problems for testing because frontier models had outgrown easier challenges.
[Ian Agol](https://math.berkeley.edu/~ianagol/) compared the situation with [Grigori Perelman's](https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Perelman/) release of one of the century's most important proofs in 2002. The Russian mathematician gave few talks about his work. Agol noted that several research teams then spent years reconstructing the missing steps.
## "\[…\] a trillion-dollar company showed up and just blasted the whole thing with TNT \[…\]"
Few responses focus on the quality of the solutions themselves. Many mathematicians instead describe shock, paralysis, and fears about their future in the profession.
[Hugo Duminil-Copin](https://www.unige.ch/math/en/section/enseignants-et-chercheurs-2/hugo-duminil-copin), a 2022 Fields Medalist, wrote, "I expected that one day we would be surpassed, and that it would happen systematically. But yesterday's announcement hit with a force I had not anticipated."
According to Duminil-Copin, OpenAI claimed results on every major unsolved problem he had publicly discussed over his career. "But not all of them. Not all at once. Not with such nonchalance."
"The shock is immense. I am paralysed." He added, "Tomorrow, we will find a way forward. \[...\] But for now, I simply don't have the energy."
[Matt Zaremsky](https://zaremsky.github.io/) described four years of steady progress toward a particular problem, with his research program producing a major advance about once a year. In his account, OpenAI stepped in once the problem had gained enough prominence.
"\[...\] it feels like we've been working on an archeological dig for 4 years, gradually discovering more and more of a really cool-looking dinosaur skeleton, and then a trillion-dollar company showed up and just blasted the whole thing with TNT, handed us the whole skeleton, and walked away." He summed up the experience as "not great."
[Tasmin Chu](https://substack.com/@tasmin) became attached to a probability theory problem as a student. It was what drew her into research. "\[...\] what I wanted more than to know that pc "AI, AI, AI, AI
> I'm begging of you, please don't take my math
> AI, AI, AI, AI
> Please don't take it just because you can"
## Researchers disagree on what remains for humans
Some researchers see reasons for optimism. [Danny Calegari](https://math.uchicago.edu/~dannyc/) said personal curiosity had guided his choice of projects for the past 15 years, and OpenAI's release hadn't affected his current work.
Calegari described a collaboration with a musician on a soundtrack for a mathematical animation. Anthropic's Claude had written the code. "If that's not worth celebrating I don't know what is."
[Constantin Kogler](https://www.ias.edu/scholars/constantin-kogler) had been working with Astra on a problem that OpenAI also claimed to have solved. He posted his own paper on arXiv a day after the company's release. "\[...\] I can't help but feel like living in a mathematical wonderland with the next field-defining idea being discovered whenever I am ready for it."
[Giovanni Mongardi](https://www.unibo.it/sitoweb/giovanni.mongardi2/en) saw a much bleaker future. "Today, something is lost forever." He described mathematicians' remaining role as "priests of the Machine-God" and feared "the future of the mind will be a desert, with no questions to guide us beyond the horizon."
Concern for younger researchers runs through nearly all the responses. [Mark Hagen](https://www.bristolmathsresearch.org/staff-profile/dr-mark-hagen/) said requests for help from distressed early-career colleagues took priority over examining the preprints that day.
[Petra Schwer](https://web.mathi.uni-heidelberg.de/ggt/schwer) said she and other mathematicians had become more guarded when discussing research. "Mistrust is spreading, and that is not good." [Mitchell Taylor](https://mitchtaylormath.ca/) said many colleagues were experiencing "severe anxiety, depression and loss of purpose."
[Martin Bridson](https://www.maths.ox.ac.uk/people/martin.bridson) acknowledged both the opportunities and the losses. But he cautioned against letting AI labs set the research agenda. "At the same time, we must resist the temptation to believe that digging insights out of announcements from AI labs will become the paramount task of our time." "We should embrace the power that the machines offer, but we should not be indentured to follow their lead."
## Months of tension have become a personal crisis
The [Association for Human Mathematics had already called for a boycott of OpenAI](https://the-decoder.com/some-mathematicians-call-for-openai-boycott-after-ai-generated-proofs-flood-their-field/), accusing the company of violating core norms of scientific research. Twenty-five Fields Medalists, including Tao and Scholze, had also issued a [joint statement](https://the-decoder.com/leading-mathematicians-fear-ai-is-making-their-field-dumber-and-warn-the-rest-of-us-is-next/) warning of a serious misalignment between the goals of the AI industry and those of mathematics.
[Tao had outlined a "Math 2.0" era](https://the-decoder.com/some-mathematicians-call-for-openai-boycott-after-ai-generated-proofs-flood-their-field/#ai-is-cracking-open-math-problems-faster-than-anyone-can-verify-the-results) in which solving problems alone could no longer be the field's central focus. The responses so far show how deeply personal this shift is for mathematicians.